ISLAM
Dr. Arnold Leder
Political
Science 4331
Fall 2024
View Image Of: The Blue Mosque (Sultan Ahmet
Mosque)/Istanbul, Turkey @ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sultan_Ahmed_Mosque#/media/File:Sultan_Ahmed_Mosque.jpg
Views of the Sulemaniye Mosque in Istanbul, Turkey @ https://www.google.com/search?q=suleymaniye+mosque+photos+istanbul&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjcsv-C2obTAhWI5IMKHTgxCKoQsAQIGQ&biw=1708&bih=840&dpr=1
For a discussion of the architecture, art, elements of
diverse origin, distinctiveness, and spiritual significance of
Islamic mosques see: Bernard
Lewis,
An Islamic Mosque
(Chapter 1, pp. 15-17.) in Bernard
Lewis, From Babel To Dragomans: Interpreting The Middle East
(Oxford University Press 2004).
Images of the Suleymaniye Mosque in Istanbul, Turkey
discussed in this essay by Bernard Lewis:
Department Of Political Science/Texas State
University http://www.polisci.txstate.edu/
Office:
UAC/Undergraduate Academic Center 355;
Telephone number: (512) 245-2143; Fax number: (512) 245-7815
Liberal Arts Computer Lab: UAC/Undergraduate Academic Center
Room 440; Website: http://www.polisci.txstate.edu/resources/computer-lab.html
For the link to the posted web version of this
syllabus as well as links to other posted
courses taught by Dr. Leder see: http://www.arnoldleder.com/
Office Hours: Office Hours for Distance Learning Format Courses:
Flexible mutually agreed on appointment days and times with
individual students using email. Communication for
appointments through email.
Dr. Leder's email address:
al04@txstate.edu
Class
Days and Times TBA
The online version of this syllabus can be accessed
@ http://www.arnoldleder.com/.
Scroll to the link for this syllabus labeled Political Science The
Politics of Extremism.
Password protected materials for this course can be viewed @ http://www.arnoldleder.com/readings/index.html.
Scroll to the section on "Terrorism". Password and user name
for access will be provided to students in the course. For
links to web syllabi for other courses taught by Dr. Leder see: http://www.arnoldleder.com/.
Link to: Texas State University
Library
Note on Links: For all indicated links in this
syllabus to the Texas State University Library please use this
link: Texas State
University Library.
A number of articles in this syllabus are accessible in pdf
(portable document format) to students at the CANVAS site of
Texas State University. A Texas State University User
Name/ID and password are required for access. Materials in this
syllabus which indicate they are accessible at TRACS have been
transferred to CANVAS in the FILES section for Political Science
4331 and are no longer accessible in TRACS. Additional
materials in pdf, if added to this syllabus and so
indicated, may also be accessed at the CANVAS site for
Political Science 4331. Please check the pdf materials at
the CANVAS site for this course. CANVAS
link: https://discovery.canvas.txstate.edu/
Texas State University Academic/Student
Calendar @ https://www.registrar.txstate.edu/persistent-links/academic-calendar/academic-calendar-student.html
B.A.
(Political Science) & BPA (Public Administration) –
PROGRAM LEARNING OUTCOMES, CIVILITY, ACADEMIC HONESTY
- Please see end of syllabus and view statements.
Students with Disabilities:
Qualified students with disabilities are entitled to reasonable
and appropriate accommodations in accordance with federal laws
including Section 504 of the 1973 Rehabilitation Act and the 1990
Americans with Disabilities Act, and the university policy UPPS
07.11.01. Students with special needs (as documented by the
Office of Disability Services) should identify themselves at the
beginning of the semester.
Note On Course & Syllabus Materials:
Students may find books, articles, links, websites, and other
materials provided in this syllabus useful and of interest.
Their listing in this syllabus, including those which are
required and recommended, does not necessarily indicate
endorsement of or agreement with any views or positions on any
issues found in these materials, websites, or on other sites to
which they may provide links.
Note On Access To Articles:
Access to articles through the Texas State University Library
@Texas State
University Library available to all Texas State
University students, requires a valid User Name and a
Password. Most of the links in this syllabus provide
direct access to the article.
Password Protected Materials: Some materials on this web syllabus are password
protected and are directly accessible @ http://www.arnoldleder.com/readings/index.html.
These materials are for student use. The password
will be provided to students in the course.
COURSE DESCRIPTION
This course is a study of the origins, development,
divisions, law, and politics of Islam. Topics covered include
Islamic Law and political institutions; the Arab and Persian roles
in Islam; the Islamic Community as a political system; major
points of the Islamic faith and their political significance; the
political and historical significance of Islamic mysticism; the
emergence of Islamism/radical Islam and the challenges of
modernity; and the status of women in Islam.
PURPOSE OF COURSE
The purpose of this course is to acquire some
understanding of Islam as a religious tradition, way of life,
and attendant perspectives for political thought and behavior,
and Islamic responses to modernity, including the emergence of
radical Islam.
COURSE ORGANIZATION & STUDENT
RESPONSIBILITIES - Distance Learning Format
Zoom class meeting times will be flexible. Generally, Zoom
meetings will occur once every week. The day and time for these
meetings will be announced.
Attendance at Zoom meetings is encouraged. Given the
difficulties faced by many students and faculty at this time
attendance at Zoom meetings will not be mandatory.
Grades
This course includes two formats. One
is lecture when appropriate and the other is discussion format
when course materials make this suitable.
Determinants of Course Grade: Required short papers,
likely no more than 3, on assigned readings and viewing
materials. Length
and specifics of these papers TBA. Dates for
submission of each of these short papers TBA.
Oral Reports & Presentations and Zoom meetings participation
when circumstances and conditions permit.
REQUIRED BOOKS
A. J. Arberry, The Koran Interpreted
A.
J.
Arberry/The Koran Interpreted
Fatima Mernissi, Beyond The Veil: Male-Female
Dynamics in Modern Muslim Society (Indiana Univ. Press 1987)
Fatima
Mernissi/Beyond
The Veil:Male-Female Dynamics in Modern Muslim Society (Indiana
Univ. Press 1987 - first published in 1975)
Fazlur Rahman, Islam (Second Edition 2002)
Fazlur
Rahman/Islam
(Second Edition-Univ. Of Chicago Press 2002 - first published in
1966)
Chapters in Fazlur Rahman's book are accessible online @
https://books.google.com/books/about/Islam.html?id=bjfnDwAAQBAJ
Read the Introduction to Fazlur Rahman/s book at this online
location indicated immediately above.
Recommended
Books:
Leila Ahmed, Women and Gender in Islam:
Historical Roots of a Modern Debate (Yale University
Press 1992)
Leila
Ahmed/Women
and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate (Yale
University Press 1992)
David Cook, Understanding Jihad
(University of California Press 2005)
David
Cook/Understanding Jihad (University of California Press 2005)
Note: The
following works by Caldwell (and the reviews), Warner &
Wenner, and Fetzer and Soper are listed here as different views on
the issue of Muslim minorities in Western Europe.
Christopher
Caldwell, Reflections
On The Revolution In Europe: Immigration, Islam, And The West
(Doubleday 2009)
Christopher
Caldwell/Reflections
On The Revolution In Europe: Immigration, Islam, And The West
(Doubleday 2009)
See these reviews of this book: Dwight
Garner/A Turning Tide in
Europe as Islam Gains Ground/NYT July 30, 2009
and Fouad
Ajami/Strangers in the Land (w/photo) NYT Sunday Book Review,
August 2, 2009.
For a perspective very different from that of Christopher
Caldwell on Muslims in Western Europe, see: Carolyn
M.
Warner, Manfred W. Wenner/Religion and the Political
Organization of Muslims in Europe, Perspectives on Politics,
Volume 4, Number 3 (September 2006), pp. 457-479. (pdf) Note: This is a Texas State University Library
permalink. A valid Texas State
University User Name and password are required to access this
article.
Joel S. Fetzer, J. Christopher Soper, Muslims
and
the
State in Britain, France, and Germany (Cambridge 2005)
Joel
S.
Fetzer, J. Christopher Soper/Muslims and the State in Britain,
France, and Germany (Cambridge 2005)
Clifford Geertz, Islam Observed: Religious
Development in Morocco and Indonesia (Yale University
Press 1968/Hardcover & University of Chicago Press 1971/Paper)
Clifford
Geertz/Islam
Observed: Religious Development in Morocco and Indonesia (Yale
University Press 1968/Hardcover & University of Chicago
Press 1971/Paper)
Mary Habeck, Knowing the Enemy: Jihadist
Ideology and the War on Terror (Yale Univ. Press 2006)
Mary
Habeck/Knowing
the Enemy: Jihadist Ideology and the War on Terror (Yale Univ.
Press 2006)
Timur Kuran, The Long Divergence: How
Islamic Law Held Back the Middle East (Princeton
University Press 2010)
Timur
Kuran/
The
Long Divergence: How Islamic Law Held Back the Middle East
(Princeton University Press 2010)
Reuben Levy, The Social Structure of
Islam: Introduction to the Sociology of Islam (Taylor
& Francis 2000 - Earlier edition Cambridge University Press
1957)
Reuben
Levy The Social Structure of Islam: Introduction to the
Sociology of Islam (Taylor & Francis 2000 - Earlier edition
Cambridge University Press 1957)
Bernard Lewis, What Went Wrong? Western Impact &
Middle Eastern Response (Oxford 2002)
Bernard
Lewis/What
Went Wrong? Western Impact & Middle Eastern Response (Oxford
2002)
E. I. J. Rosenthal, Political Thought In
Medieval Islam: An Introductory Outline (Cambridge
University Press 1962)
E.
I.
J. Rosenthal/Political Thought In Medieval Islam: An
Introductory Outline (Cambridge University Press 1962)
"Islam knows no distinction between a spiritual and a
temporal realm, between religious and secular activities. Both
realms form a unity under the all-embracing authority of the Sharī'a. (p. 8.)
... politics, ... is the scene
of religion as life on this earth as long as the law of the
state is the Sharī'a." (p. 9.)
[boldface added]
Olivier Roy, Globalized Islam: The Search
For A New Ummah (Columbia University Press 2004 &
2006)
Olivier
Roy, Globalized Islam: The Search For A New Ummah (Columbia
University Press 2004 & 2006)
Philip Carl Salzman, Culture and Conflict in the
Middle East (Humanity Books 2008)
Philip
Carl
Salzman/Culture and Conflict in the Middle East (Humanity Books
2008)
Joseph Schacht, An Introduction To Islamic
Law (Oxford Clarendon Press, 1964 & 1983)
Joseph
Schacht/An
Introduction To Islamic Law (Oxford Clarendon Press, 1964 &
1983)
From the book
description at Barnes & Noble:
"... a broad account of the present knowledge of the history and
outlines the system of Islamic law. Showing that Islamic law is the key to
understanding the essence of one of the great world religions,
this book explores how it still influences the laws of
contemporary Islamic states, and is in itself a remarkable
manifestation of legal thought." (boldface added)
J. Spencer Trimingham, The Sufi Orders in Islam
(Oxford University Press 1998 with Forward by John O. Voll,
original published in 1971)
J.
Spencer
Trimingham/The Sufi Orders in Islam (Oxford University Press
1998 with Forward by John O. Voll, original published in 1971)
From the Oxford
University Press book description:
"Sufism, the name given to Islamic mysticism, has been the subject
of many studies, but the orders through which the organizational
aspect of the Sufi spirit was expressed has been neglected. The Sufi Orders in Islam
is one of the earliest modern examinations of the historical
development of Sufism and is considered a classic work in numerous
sources of Islamic studies today. ... a clear and detailed account
of the formation and development of the Sufi schools and orders
(tariqahs) from the second century of Islam until modern times."
VIDEOS
Islam (The Smithsonian)
Women and Islam: Islamic Conversations/Leila
Ahmed
For a preview of "Women and Islam", see: http://www.films.com/id/7766/Women_and_Islam.htm
- Scroll to preview clip.
Islam:
Empire
of Faith (PBS)
For a critical review of this PBS film, see: Martin Kramer,
Islam for Viewers Like You/The Middle East Quarterly/Winter 2002
Vol. IX:No.1 __________________________________________________________________________________
Course Title: Islam
Overview Of
Course - Scroll to each
topic.
Topics
I. The Middle East: Culture &
History
II. The Origins of Islam
III. Islam as a Way of Life
IV. The Major Divisions in Islam
V. Islamic Mysticism/Sufism
VI. Issues in Contemporary Islam:
Islamism/Radical Islam; Democracy
VII. Women in Islam
TOPICS FOR LECTURE & ASSIGNED &
RECOMMENDED READINGS & WEB SITES
I. The Middle East: Culture
& History
1. An overview of Middle Eastern Culture
2. The Pre-Islamic Period/Jahiliyyah
3. The Early Islamic Period
Internet
Sources
On Islam/Fordham University(Comprehensive Site With Links For
Many Aspects Of The Islamic Experience)
Middle
East Maps UT Library Online/Perry-Castaneda Map
Collection/Middle East Maps
Map
Of
Geographic Distribution Of Religions/MiddleEast
Readings:
Fazlur
Rahman, Islam, Introduction (Google Books preview, pp.
1-9. p. 10 is not included in this preview.)
@ https://books.google.com/books?id=bjfnDwAAQBAJ&newbks=0&printsec=frontcover&dq=inauthor:%22Fazlur+Rahman%22&hl=en#v=onepage&q&f=true
Scroll to the Introduction to Fazlur Rahman's book, Islam.
For an analysis of the influence of Arab culture, the
principle
of "balanced opposition", and tribal
organization on the rise of Islam, see: Philip Carl
Salzman/The Middle East's Tribal DNA/Middle East Quarterly,
Winter 2008, pp. 23-33. This article is drawn from his
book Culture
and
Conflict in the Middle East (Humanity Books 2008).
For a description of Arab poetry and traditions in the
pre-Islamic period, see the classic study Reynold A.
Nicholson, A Literary History
of the Arabs (First Edition T. Fisher Unwin 1907;
Taylor & Francis 2000; Digital Edition January, 2007).
Read: Chapter
III
Pre-Islamic Poetry, Manners,
and Religion, pp. 71-140 and see page
77 on The
Qasida
or Ode and page 131 on Oral
Tradition.
For a discussion of the influence of poetry in contemporary
radical Islam, see: Robyn Creswell and Bernard Haykel, "Why
Jihadists Write Poetry", The New Yorker, June 8, 2015 @ http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/06/08/battle-lines-jihad-creswell-and-haykel
Reuben
Levy,
The Social Structure of Islam, Chapter I (pp. 53 through 90) - The Grades Of Society In Islam
Note:
While understanding Arab culture in the pre-Islamic period and its
influence in the development of Islam are essential to the study
of Islam, later developments and the important influence of other
cultures and traditions in the larger Islamic world, as far
removed geographically as Indonesia and other areas, should not be
overlooked. To do so is to ignore important dimensions of
the Islamic experience.
See: Clifford
Geertz/Islam Observed: Religious Development in Morocco and
Indonesia (Yale University Press 1968/Hardcover & University
of Chicago Press 1971/Paper)
For online access and a limited preview of
Clifford Geertz, Islam
Observed, see: https://www.google.com/books/edition/_/d_ra-y_50GsC?hl=en&gbpv=1&pg=PP1
Note: Access
using this link requires a late or recent version of most
browsers. Older versions of browsers may not work with this
link.
Publisher's
Comment
on Clifford Geertz, Islam
Observed (University of Chicago Press):
"Mr. Geertz begins his argument by outlining the problem
conceptually and providing an overview of the two countries. He
then traces the evolution of
their classical religious styles which, with disparate settings
and unique histories, produced strikingly different spiritual
climates. So in Morocco, the Islamic conception of life came to
mean activism, moralism, and intense individuality, while in
Indonesia the same concept emphasized aestheticism, inwardness,
and the radical dissolution of personality." (boldface
added)
Clifford Geertz:
"I have attempted both to lay out a general framework for the
comparative analysis of religion and to apply it to a study of the
development of a supposedly single creed, Islam, in two quite
contrasting civilizations, the Indonesian and the Moroccan." (page
ix of the author's
Preface)
"Religious faith, even when it is fed from a common source, is as
much a particularizing force as a generalizing one, and indeed
whatever universality a given religious tradition manages to
attain arises from its ability to engage a widening set of
individual, even idiosyncratic, conceptions of life and yet
somehow sustain and elaborate them all." (page 14)
Nikki
R.
Keddie, Symbol and Sincerity
in Islam, Studia
Islamica, Vol. 19, 1963, pp. 27-63.
This is a direct access permalink @ the Texas State University
Library. A valid Texas State
University user name and password are required. Scroll down
to the article in pdf.
Note:
Older browsers may not work for access to periodicals at the Texas State University Library. New
or recent browsers are best. On some browsers, it may be necessary
or more convenient to save the article to desktop as pdf with the
extension .pdf following the title of the article.
Excerpt from the
conclusion of this article: "It would seem a serious
error to read the works of either traditional or modern Muslim
authors as if they had been written for a homogeneous audience in
a liberal, secular society. Often Western criticisms of modern
Muslim thinkers seem to focus on the literal accuracy of what they
say rather than on the needs and traditions which lead them to
express themselves in a certain fashion. Greater awareness of
these needs and traditions could lead to greater respect for the
useful work performed by modern Muslim thinkers in bridging the
painful gap between traditional values and modern needs."
This article by Nikki R. Keddie is accessible in the Files section
of the CANVAS site for Political Science 4331/Islamic Law &
Politics.
For some evidence of the more recent appearance of a less tolerant
version of Islam in Indonesia, see: Calvin
Sims/Indonesia:
Gambling That Tolerance Will Trump Fear/NYT April 15, 2007.
For indications of the resilience of Indonesia's
traditional, moderate version of Islam, see: Norimitisu
Onishi/Indonesia's
Voters Retreat From Radical Islam/NYT April 25, 2009.
For a description of the integration of Islam and
pre-Islamic folk traditions (and the persistence of these
traditions) in an Egyptian village in the 1950's, see: Ḥamed
Ammar/Growing
Up in an Egyptian Village: Silwa, Province of Aswan (Taylor
& Francis, 2003 Reprint - originally published in 1954).
In this book, see especially: Chapter
Three
- Folk Life And Social Change
In The Village, pp. 67-84.
"According to the villagers, the 'ashraf'
(people of distinguished descent being related to the Prophet)
have a better chance of salvation than others, a notion which, of
course, satisfies the villagers' ego as they consider themselves
descendants of the Prophet. The persistence of the religious
prerogatives of the 'ashraf' goes to show that the central conception of Islam in
the equality of all believers has not entirely supplanted the
Arab reverence for distinguished genealogy." (page
74.) [boldfaced added]
"It is no exaggeration to say that the folk culture of the village
is permeated by religious sanctions and moral values derived from
the Islamic traditions as revealed in the Koran and also infused with rituals and beliefs
of an older tradition." (page
75.) [boldfaced added]
On the questions of understanding and
conceptualizing Islam, see the much discussed book by Shahab Ahmed, What Is Islam?: The Importance of
Being Islamic (Princeton University Press 2015) @ http://press.princeton.edu/titles/10587.html. The first chapter of this book is accessible
in pdf at this same 1ocation.
Princeton University Press Description of this
book:
What is Islam? How do we grasp a human and historical phenomenon
characterized by such variety and contradiction? What is
"Islamic" about Islamic philosophy or Islamic art? Should we
speak of Islam or of islams? Should we distinguish the Islamic
(the religious) from the Islamicate (the cultural)? Or should we
abandon "Islamic" altogether as an analytical term?
In What Is Islam?, Shahab Ahmed presents
a bold new conceptualization of Islam that challenges dominant
understandings grounded in the categories of "religion" and
"culture" or those that privilege law and scripture. He argues
that these modes of thinking obstruct us from understanding
Islam, distorting it, diminishing it, and rendering it
incoherent.
What Is Islam? formulates a new conceptual
language for analyzing Islam. It presents a new paradigm of how
Muslims have historically understood divine revelation—one that
enables us to understand how and why Muslims through history
have embraced values such as exploration, ambiguity,
aestheticization, polyvalence, and relativism, as well as
practices such as figural art, music, and even wine drinking as
Islamic. It also puts forward a new understanding of the
historical constitution of Islamic law and its relationship to
philosophical ethics and political theory
A book that is certain to provoke debate and
significantly alter our understanding of Islam, What Is
Islam? reveals how Muslims have historically conceived of
and lived with Islam as norms and truths that are at once
contradictory yet coherent.
For a series of essays addressing the questions
and issues raised in each chapter of Shahab
Ahmed's book, What Is Islam?, see:
What is Islam? Forum - An Introduction August
19, 2016 @ http://marginalia.lareviewofbooks.org/islam-forum-introduction/.
Scroll to the links to the essays.
Note: Zareena Grewal's review essay “The
Problem with Being Islamic: Definitional and Theoretical Limits
and Legacies,” of Shahab Ahmed’s third
chapter “Religion and Secular, Sacred and Profane,
Theocentric and Anthropocentric, Total Social Fact, Family
Resemblance” is accessible @ http://marginalia.lareviewofbooks.org/problem-islamic-definitional-theoretical-limits-legacies-zareena-grewal/.
From the closing lines of What is
Islam?:
“This book has sought not so much to define, as to bring
into definition–to bring into view, to discern
and to descry–Islam in its plenitude of meaning. Islam,
meaning-making for the self by one-fifth of humanity, is Islam–it
is not anything else–and should be conceptualized, understood
and appreciated as such; in terms which cohere with its
meanings and by which its meanings cohere. By not employing
language appropriate to the meaning at stake, and thus by not
recognizing Islam for what it is, we–Muslims and non-Muslims–at
best misrepresent, and at worst commit an outright injustice to
the human and historical existences and endeavours of one-fifth
of humanity. We also do an injustice to ourselves by preventing
ourselves from apprehending and benefiting from what those
existences and endeavours have to offer us by way of
understanding and experiencing the human predicament, as well as
from apprehending and benefitting from what those existences and
endeavours have to offer us by way of making meaning for
ourselves. Let us understand, apprehend and benefit from the
importance of being Islamic.” (boldface
added)
For related observations on the diverse
dimensions of the Islamic experience with a focus on early
Islam, see:
Robert F. Worth, "In the Attic of Early Islam", New York
Review of Books, August 24, 2016 @ http://www.nybooks.com/daily/2016/08/24/in-the-attic-of-early-islam-shihab-al-din-al-nuwayri/
This is a review essay of: Shihab al-Din al-Nuwayri, The Ultimate Ambition
in the Arts of Erudition, edited by Elias Muhanna
(penguinrandomhouse, August 2016).
From Robert
F. Worth's essay:
"... this bizarre, fascinating book that illustrate(s) the sprawlingly
heterodox reality of the early centuries of Islam, so
different from the crude puritanical myths purveyed by
modern-day jihadis.
(boldface added)
... This, I think, is what the late scholar Shahab Ahmed meant
when he wrote in his posthumous book What Is Islam? that a
true understanding of Islam must “come to terms with—indeed,
be coherent with—the capaciousness, complexity, and, often, outright
contradiction that obtains within” the
religion’s lived history".
(boldface added)
On the diversity of Islam and the
concept of Muslim unity, see:
Faisal Devji, "Against Muslim unity", Aeon, July 12,
2016 @ https://aeon.co/essays/the-idea-of-unifying-islam-is-a-recent-invention-and-a-bad-one.
From Faisal Devji's essay:
"Even sophisticated people speak of Islam as if it is one thing.
The devout, the haters and the indifferent often share this
belief in Muslim unity. And for them all there is no greater
display of Muslim unity than the Hajj (Pilgrimage).
... Like the idea of the three monotheistic brothers, the
idea of Muslim unity is recent, well-meaning and highly
misleading. (boldface added)
... Today, calls for Muslim unity
come from so-called militants and moderates alike. Such calls
for Muslim unity do not date back much before the 20th century.
To be sure, the ideal of universal agreement in Islam might have
existed before. But it seldom constituted a political or even
religious project beyond fairly circumscribed arenas of debate.
On the contrary, the internal schisms and conflicts of Muslim
societies demonstrated a sense of confidence and comfort with
disagreement as a political necessity."
- Video: Islam: Empire of
Faith
- For a critical review of this PBS film, see: Martin Kramer,
Islam for Viewers Like You/The Middle East Quarterly/Winter
2002 Vol. IX: No. 1.
II. The Origins of Islam
1. Mohammed & The Holy Koran The
Koran-Browse
Recommended:
Toby Lester, "What Is The Koran?" TheAtlantic,
January1999, Vol. 283 Issue 1, pp.
43-56.
Texas State University permalink. A valid Texas State
University User Name and password are required for access.
Oleg
Grabar/Seeing
and Believing: The Image of the prophet in Islam - the real
story/The New Republic, November 4, 2009, Vol. 240, Issue 20,
pp. 33-37, 5 pages. (pdf)
This is a Texas State University library permalink
for
direct access to the article by Oleg Grabar. A valid Texas State University User Name and
password are required for access.
Abstract: The
article discusses representations of the Prophet Muhammad and
Islam. The September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks led to the
creation of a climate of fear and politically charged events. In
2005 a cartoon was published in a Danish newspaper showing the
Prophet Muhammad and this incited riots in Muslim regions that
resulted in deaths. Many Muslims allege that representations of
the Prophet Muhammad are forbidden in Islam and are sins meant to
be punished.
2. Mohammed & the Arab Concept of History
Readings: Rahman, Chapters 1, 2.
Arberry, The Holy Koran Interpreted, all,
including Arberry's preface.
Khaleel
Mohammed/Assessing
English Translations of the Qur'an/The Middle East
Quarterly/Spring 2005 Vol. XII No. 2.
Neil
MacFarquhar/New
Translation Prompts Debate on Islamic Verse/NYT March 25, 2007
Edward
Rothstein/Abraham's
Progeny, and Their Texts (w/images & links)/NYT Arts
Section October 23, 2010
“Three Faiths,” a new exhibition at the New York Public
Library, examines the braid of belief that binds Judaism,
Christianity and Islam.
See image of: "Muhammad Leading the Other Prophets," from a
16th-century Turkish manuscript @ http://www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2010/10/23/JUMP-FAITHS-1.html.
III. Islam as a Way of Life
1. Perceptions of Allah
2. The Islamic Community
3. Major Points of Faith & their Political
Significance
4. The Pillars of Islam
Luca Locatelli, "Mecca Goes Mega", NYT, June 8, 2016
@ http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/12/magazine/mecca-goes-mega.html
A building boom in the city’s sacred center has created a
dazzling, high-tech 21st-century pilgrimage. (See slide show
accompanying article.)
Michael
Gilsenan/And you, what are you doing here?/Review Essay on Abdellah
Hammoudi, A Season in
Mecca: Narrative of a Pilgrimage (2006)/London Review Of Books/)
October 19, 2006 Vol. 28, No. 20. See also: (Translation
Edition
- Hill and Wang January 2006 - from the 2005 French original Une
saison
à la Mecque)
"With all the contemporary media and political noise about
Islam, the changing nature of the pilgrimage and the individual
experience of undertaking it are in danger of being lost or
relegated to a few lines in a local newspaper or glimpses of
family videos and photos. How do different pilgrims now live the
pilgrimage, more than a century after the Jeddah? What
stories does a pilgrim tell of such a regulated and, for many,
exhausting as well as transcendent experience? What kinds of
reflection does the haj provoke after more than a hundred years of
transformation?
Abdellah Hammoudi’s narrative, A Season in Mecca,
offers one response. It is as much a subtle, complex meditation
as it is an example of the ‘art of reportage’ (for which it won
a Lettre Ulysses Award in Berlin in 2005). It is a commentary on
one Arab intellectual’s modern dilemmas as well as on the haj as
he experienced it in 1999 and as he continues to apprehend it in
his writing. Perhaps it would be better to say, as he struggles
to apprehend it, because this sense of struggle gives the
writing much of its deep interest."
Hassan
M.
Fattah/The Price of Progress: Transforming Islam's Holiest
Site (Mecca Journal)/NYT March 08, 2007
Thanassis
Cambanis/Celebration
Marks End of Ramadan in Lebanon/NYT/October 13, 2007
Nicolai
Ouroussoff/New
Look for Mecca: Gargantuan and Gaudy (w/photos &
links)/NYT December 30, 2010
The Saudi government is being criticized for construction
projects in the historic core of Mecca that many find appalling.
"It is an architectural absurdity. Just south of the Grand
Mosque in Mecca, the Muslim world’s holiest site, a kitsch
rendition of London’s Big Ben is nearing completion. Called the
Royal Mecca Clock Tower, it will be one of the tallest buildings
in the world, the centerpiece of a complex that is housing a
gargantuan shopping mall, an 800-room hotel and a prayer hall
for several thousand people. Its muscular form, an unabashed
knockoff of the original, blown up to a grotesque scale, will be
decorated with Arabic inscriptions and topped by a
crescent-shape spire in what feels like a cynical nod to Islam’s
architectural past. To make room for it, the Saudi government
bulldozed an 18th-century Ottoman fortress and the hill it stood
on.
...
That mentality is dividing the
holy city of Mecca — and the pilgrimage experience — along
highly visible class lines, with the rich sealed inside
exclusive air-conditioned high-rises encircling the Grand
Mosque and the poor pushed increasingly to the periphery. (boldface
added)
...
But the Vegas-like aura of these projects can deflect attention
from the real crime: the way the developments are deforming what
by all accounts was a fairly diverse and unstratified city. The
Mecca Clock Tower will be surrounded by a half-dozen luxury
high-rises, each designed in a similar Westminster-meets-Wall
Street style and sitting on a mall that is meant to evoke
traditional souks. Built at various heights at the edge of the
Grand Mosque’s courtyard, and fronted by big arched
portes-cocheres, they form a postmodern pastiche that means to
evoke the differences of a real city but will do little to mask
the project’s mind-numbing homogeneity.
Like the luxury boxes that
encircle most sports stadiums, the apartments will allow the
wealthy to peer directly down at the main event from the
comfort of their suites without having to mix with the
ordinary rabble below. (boldface added)
At the same time, the scale of development has pushed
middle-class and poor residents further and further from the
city center. 'I don’t know where they go,' Mr. Angawi said. 'To
the outskirts of Mecca, or they come to Jidda. Mecca is being
cleansed of Meccans.'
The changes are likely to have as much of an effect on the
spiritual character of the Grand Mosque as on Mecca’s urban
fabric. Many people told me that the intensity of the experience
of standing in the mosque’s courtyard has a lot to do with its
relationship to the surrounding mountains. Most of these
represent sacred sites in their own right and their looming
presence imbues the space with a powerful sense of intimacy.
...
The issue is not just run-of-the-mill class conflict. The city’s
makeover also reflects a split between those who champion
turbocharged capitalism and those who think it should stop at
the gates of Mecca, which they see as the embodiment of an
Islamic ideal of egalitarianism."
See also: Martin Kramer, "Mecca: You don't know
what you've got 'til it's gone" - a gallery on Flickr @ https://www.flickr.com/photos/martin_kramer/galleries/72157627940174432/
5. The Shariya
"In most Islamic countries, ... religion is even
more powerful in internal than in international affairs.
[There is] an intimate and essential relationship in Islam between
religion and politics that has no parallel in any other major
religion.
In Islam there was from the beginning an interpenetration of
religion and government, of belief and power, ..." Bernard
Lewis/The
Multiple Identities Of The Middle East (Schocken Books 1998),
pp. 27-28.
E.
I.
J. Rosenthal/Political Thought In Medieval Islam: An
Introductory Outline (Cambridge University Press 1962)
"We must realize that no matter what modern research has
established with regard to the origin and development of Muslim
law and its threefold foundation in Qur'an, Sunna and Hadith, it
is, in a Muslim's consciousness, divine law, perfect and binding
on all members of the Muslim community. Otherwise we cannot hope
to understand what was in the minds of the Muslim writers whose
political thought we consider. Our interpretation must take full
account of their basic attitude. (page
7 & page
8)
...
Islam knows no distinction between a spiritual and a temporal
realm, between religious and secular activities. Both realms form
a unity under the all-embracing authority of the Sharia. (page
8)
... politics, ... is the scene
of religion as life on this earth as long as the law of the
state is the Sharia." (page
9) [boldface added]
Hadith Database/The
Hadith of the Prophet Muhammad @ https://sunnah.com/
Sahih Bukhari @ https://sunnah.com/bukhari
6. Shariya in Sunni Islam & Halakha in
Traditional Judaism: A Comparative Note
7. Shariya in Islam & Sacred Texts & "The
Higher Criticism" in the Western Religious Experience: A
Comparative Note
See: Peter
Steinfels/[Beliefs]Differences
in Biblical Approaches Are Irreconcilable, Scholar Says/NYT
September 15, 2007
David
Plotz/How to Read the Bible:
A skeptical believer reclaims the Good Book/International Herald
Tribune/September 14, 2007. This is a
review of: James
L.
Kugel/How to Read the Bible: A Guide to Scripture, Then and Now
(Free Press 2007). Read "Preliminaries",
an excerpt from this book.
Rebecca
Newberger
Goldstein/The Political and the Divine/NYT Sunday Book Review
September 16, 2007 This is a review of: Mark
Lilla,
A Stillborn God: Religion, Politics, and the Modern West (Knopf
2007)
See also: Mark
Lilla/The
Politics of God/NYT Sunday Magazine August 19, 2007.
This essay is also noted below in section VI. Issues in Contemporary Islam: Islamism/Radical
Islam; Democracy of
this
syllabus with an excerpt
from the essay.
For an analysis of Western (British)
"invention" of a religious tradition, Hinduism, assumed to be as
organized and theologically coherent as Christianity and Islam,
see:
Pankaj Mishra, "How the British invented Hinduism", New
Statesman, August 26, 2002
@ https://www.newstatesman.com/node/156145
"By reviving the
Hindu religion, the middle classes of India hope to turn their
country into a world power."
...
Certainly, most Hindus themselves felt little need for precise
self-descriptions, except when faced with questions about religion
on official forms. Long after their encounter with the
monotheistic religions of Islam and Christianity, they continued
to define themselves through their overlapping allegiances to
family, caste, linguistic group, region and devotional sect.
Religion to them was more unselfconscious practice than rigid
belief. Their rituals and deities varied greatly."
Mosques
Around The World
View Image Of: The
Blue
Mosque (Sultan Ahmet Mosque)/Istanbul, Turkey
For a discussion of the architecture, art,
elements of diverse origin, distinctiveness, and spiritual
significance of Islamic mosques see: Bernard
Lewis,
An Islamic Mosque
(Chapter 1, pp. 15-17.) in Bernard
Lewis, From Babel To Dragomans: Interpreting The Middle East
(Oxford University Press 2004). (revisited)
Images of the Suleymaniye Mosque in Istanbul, Turkey
discussed in this essay by Bernard Lewis:
A
view of the Sulemaniye Mosque in Istanbul, Turkey
The
interior_of
the Suleymaniye Mosque in Istanbul,Turkey
Adhan (Call to Prayer) video clip @ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2zL6CfwH98
Readings: Rahman, Chapters 3, 4, 6.
Michael
Slackman/A
Compass That Can Clash With Modern Life: Eygpt's Muslims Seek
Fatwas on Issues Great and Small/NYT June 12, 2007
Photo:
Consultation
in the Al Azhar Mosque in Cairo (from Slackman article above)
Lydia
Polgreen/In
Nigeria, the Quest for a 'Humane Shariah' (photos)/NYT
December 1, 2007
Elaine
Sciolino/Britain
Grapples With Role for Islamic Justice (w/photos)/NYT November
19, 2008
Recommended:
Joseph
Schacht/An
Introduction To Islamic Law
"Islamic law is the epitome of
Islamic thought, the most typical manifestation of the Islamic
way of life, the core and kernel of Islam itself. The
very term fiḳh,
'knowledge, shows that early Islam regarded knowledge of the
sacred Law as the knowledge par
excellence. Theology has never been able to achieve a
comparable importance in Islam; only mysticism was strong enough
to challenge the ascendancy of the Law over the minds of the
Muslims, and often proved victorious. ... it is impossible to understand Islam
without understanding Islamic law." , p. 1.
(boldface added)
E.
I.
J. Rosenthal/Political Thought In Medieval Islam: An
Introductory Outline (Cambridge University Press 1962)
Reuben
Levy,
The Social Structure of Islam, Chapter IV (pp. 150 through 190)
- Islamic Jurisprudence
Reuben
Levy,
The Social Structure of Islam, Chapter VI (pp. 242 through 270)
- Usage, Custom And Secular
Law Under Islam
For a discussion of contemporary financial transactions
and matters within the framework of Shariya, see:
Jeremy
Harding/The Money that Prays/London Review of Books, Vol. 31,
No. 8, April 30, 2009.
"Sharia Finance:
Last September, as dust and debris from the tellers’ floors began
raining onto the empty vaults below, a note of satisfaction was
sounded by bankers in the Arab world. Financial institutions
sticking to the tenets of Islam, they announced, were largely
immune from the debt crisis. Devout Muslims may lend and borrow
under certain conditions; they can even buy and sell debt in the
form of ‘Islamic’ bonds, but most other kinds of debt trading are
frowned on." (boldface added)
Timur
Kuran/
The
Long Divergence: How Islamic Law Held Back the Middle East
(Princeton University Press 2010)
IV. The Major Divisions in
Islam
1. Sunni & Shi'a Islam
For a description of the diversity of population groups in Shi'a
dominated Iran, see:
Philip Carl
Salzman/Persians and Others: Iran's Minority Politics (with
maps)/blogs.law.harvard.edu/mesh/April 14, 2009
"There is a natural tendency to reify countries and think of
them as unitary entities, often indicated by calling countries
“nations” and presuming a homogeneity and uniformity among the
population. But this reification and assumption of homogeneity
are almost always inaccurate and misleading. In the case of
Iran, it would be a great error to think of the population as
being homogeneous, for the people of Iran are in fact quite
diverse. There are ethnic, linguistic, organizational, and
religious differences among Iranians."
2. Different
Spiritual Climates & Different Islamic Conceptions of Life
Readings: Clifford
Geertz/Islam Observed: Religious Development in Morocco and
Indonesia (Yale University Press 1968/Hardcover &
University of Chicago Press 1971/Paper) (revisited)
Publisher's
Comment
(University of Chicago Press):
"Mr. Geertz begins his argument by outlining the problem
conceptually and providing an overview of the two countries. He
then traces the evolution of their classical religious styles
which, with disparate settings and unique histories, produced
strikingly different spiritual climates. So in Morocco, the
Islamic conception of life came to mean activism, moralism, and
intense individuality, while in Indonesia the same concept
emphasized aestheticism, inwardness, and the radical dissolution
of personality."
Clifford Geertz:
"I have attempted both to lay out a general framework for the
comparative analysis of religion and to apply it to a study of
the development of a supposedly single creed, Islam, in two
quite contrasting civilizations, the Indonesian and the
Moroccan." (page ix of
the author's Preface)
"Religious faith, even when it is fed from a commmon source, is
as much a particularizing force as a generalizing one, and
indeed whatever universality a given religious tradition manages
to attain arises from its ability to engage a widening set of
individual, even idiosyncratic, conceptions of life and yet
somehow sustain and elaborate them all." (page 14)
For some evidence of the more recent appearance of a less
tolerant version of Islam in Indonesia, see: Calvin
Sims/Indonesia:
Gambling That Tolerance Will Trump Fear/NYT April 15, 2007.
For indications of the resilience of Indonesia's traditional,
moderate version of Islam, see: Norimitisu
Onishi/Indonesia's
Voters Retreat From Radical Islam/NYT April 25, 2009.
People in the world’s most populous Muslim nation are punishing
narrowly religious parties at the polls, going against a trend in
other Islamic countries.
'On a deeper level, some of the parties’ fundamentalist measures
seem to have alienated moderate Indonesians. While Indonesia has a long tradition of
moderation, it was badly destabilized with the end of
military rule in 1998, which gave rise to Islamist politicians who
preached righteousness and to some hard-core elements, who
practiced violence. The country has only recently achieved a
measure of stability.
...
'People in general do not feel
that there should be an integration of faith and politics,' said
Azyumardi Azra, director of the graduate school at Syarif
Hidayatullah State Islamic University. 'Even though more and more
Muslims, in particular women, have become more Islamic and have a
growing attachment to Islam, that does not translate into voting
behavior.'
...
The Islamic parties’ 2004 surge occurred around the time that
Indonesian terrorists were attacking hotels and nightclubs popular
among Westerners, as well as the Australian Embassy here. A
growing number of communities were adopting Shariah as some of the
smaller, more hard-line Islamic parties also pushed to insert
Islamic law in the Constitution.
The hard-line stance, though, was
at odds with the attitudes of Indonesians; most of them practice
a moderate version of Islam and were attracted to the Islamic
parties for nonreligious reasons.
...
The parties angered many Indonesians by pressing hard on several
symbolic religious issues, like a vague 'antipornography' law that
could be used to ban everything from displays of partial nudity to
yoga. The governor of West Java, a member of the Prosperous
Justice Party, tried to ban a
dance called jaipong, deeming it too erotic, but many people
view it as part of their cultural heritage.
...
Despite the Islamic parties’ decline, they remain influential,
analysts say. The country’s major secular parties, including
President Yudhoyono’s Democratic Party, have courted them and
their supporters. And the Prosperous Justice Party, despite its
minor gain of less than one percentage point, is pressing to
increase the number of ministers it has in the coalition
government to four from three.
'It’s still not clear where they stand on many issues like freedom
of expression, morality, the place of women,' said Ahmad Suaedy,
director of the Wahid Institute, a research organization based
here. The agenda of many people inside the party is still to
Islamize Indonesia, and that’s a constraint on democracy.' "
(boldface added)
Readings: Rahman, Chapter 10.
Michael
Slackman/For
Iran's Shiites, a Celebration of Faith and Waiting/NYT August
30, 2007
Andrea DiCenzo, "From Iraq, an Intimate Glimpse
of the Religious Holiday of Arbaeen" (Photographs are included
with the text.), NYT, November 18, 2020
(updated from November 9, 2020)
Every year, millions of pilgrims descend on the
central Iraqi city of Karbala to commemorate the Shiite holiday
of Arbaeen, one of the largest organized gatherings in the
world.
From this article: "... a spectacular
display of grief, mourning and religious ecstasy. It
commemorates the death of one of Shiite Islam's most important
leaders, Imam Hussein, a grandson of the Prophet Muhammad."
@ https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/09/travel/arbaeen-karbala-iraq.html?searchResultPosition=1
Note: This article may load slowly due to
the large number of photographs included with the article.
V. Islamic Mysticism/Sufism
1. Mysticism: The Insights of Gershom Scholem
Gershom
Scholem/Major
Trends In Jewish Mysticism (Schocken Books 1946, 1995 edition
w/Foreword by Robert Alter)
""... mystical religion seeks to transform the God whom it
encounters in the peculiar religious consciousness of its own
social environment from an object of dogmatic knowledge into a
novel and living experience and intuition. In
addition, it also seeks to interpret this experience in a new way.
... the outward forms of mystical religion within the orbit of a
given religion are to a large extent shaped by the positive
content and values recognized and glorified in that
religion." (p. 10.)
2. Sufism "Follow the path to Allah as a
flower leans to the sun." (A Sufi saying)
"It (Sufism) is a sphere of spiritual experience which
runs parallel to the main stream of Islamic consciousness deriving
from phrophetic revelation and comprehended within the Sharī'a and
theology.
...
Sufism was a natural development within Islam .. The outcome was
an Islamic mysticism following distinctive Islamic lines of
development." J.
Spencer
Trimingham/The Sufi Orders in Islam (1971 & 1998), pp. 1-2.
Sufis/SufiOrders
Whirling Dervishes: video clip @ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-6wLenLAdNs&search=Dervish
Sufi "Chant", video clip @
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jUOqFhWGX_w&search=Sufi
Sufi Women Chechnya, video clip @ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tx6dwa4u8Lg
Readings: Rahman, Chapters 8, 9.
For a detailed description of the origins of Sufism,
important Sufis figures, and excerpts from Sufi poems, see:
Reynold
A. Nicholson, A Literary
History of the Arabs, pp. 227-235-accessible beginning on page
227 and pp. 383-404-accessible
beginning on page
383.
For a discussion of Sufi art, with a slide show, see:
Holland
Cotter/The
Many Voices of Enlightenment (Art Review | 'Light
of the Sufis' - w/slide show)/NYT June
12, 2009
Many voices is what you find in an exquisite show called
“Light of the Sufis” in the newly reinstalled Islamic galleries
at the Brooklyn Museum.
"'What’s in your head — throw it away! What’s in your hand —
give it up! Whatever happens — don’t turn away from it.' That’s
how a 10th-century Persian spiritual master — Abu Said ibn
Abil-Khair was his name — defined the Islamic devotional
practice known as Sufism. Countless other definitions have been
proposed since, almost as many as for Islam itself.
Religions and spiritual movements are complicated things, and
accurate descriptions of them are bound to be contradictory.
Sufism, like Islam, is both mystical and practical, embracing
and exclusionary, pacific and assertive, ascetic and sensual,
free form and discipline bound. Such oppositions aren’t a
problem. They generate the unifying friction that makes culture
tick."
Images of Sufi Art:
“Portrait
of
a Sufi,”Deccan India, 17th century.
Layla
Visits
Majnun in the grove, a page from an 17th-century Indian
manuscript.
Spiritual yearning is often expressed in terms of erotic
attraction. One of the grand romances of popular Arabic
literature was the Romeo-and-Juliet tale of Majnun and Layla,
who fell in love.
In many iterations of the tale, Majnun is a prototype of the
Sufi who has become, in the words of the poet Farid al-Din
Attar, “a dead body, a nonexistent heart and a soul scorched
away,” an ego reduced by love to an ash on the arm of God.
Chen Malul, "The Story of Layla and Majnun -
Romeo and Juliet of the East", Islamic Manuscripts, The
Librarians, December 23, 2020
@ https://blog.nli.org.il/en/layla-and-majnun/
“A
Princely
Figure and a Dervish,” by Isfahan.
While global politics has made Islam part of our
consciousness, we hear little about Sufism and its long history.
The term “sufi” probably derives from an Arabic word for wool.
Certain followers of Sufism were called “dervishes,” a term
related to a Persian word for poor.
For a report on Sufis at war with extremist Muslims in
Somalia, see:
Jeffrey
Gettleman/For
Somalia, Chaos Breeds Religious War (w/slide show &
photos)/NYT May 24, 2009
The Sufi scholars are part of a broad, moderate Islamist
movement that Western nations are counting on to repel Somalia’s
increasingly powerful Islamist extremists.
Photo: Islamist Versus Islamist @ http://www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2009/05/24/world/24somalia_CA3.ready.html.
Moderate Sufi scholars recently did what so many others have
chosen to do in anarchic Somalia: They picked up guns and
entered the killing business, in this case to fight back against
... one of the most fearsome extremist Muslim groups in Africa.
Sabrina
Tavernise/Mystical
Form of Islam Suits Sufis in Pakistan/NYT February 26, 2010
In modern times, Sufism, a mystical form of Islam, has been
challenged in Pakistan by a stricter form of Islam that dominates
in Saudi Arabia.
Recommended Reading:
J.
Spencer
Trimingham/The Sufi Orders in Islam (1971 & 1998)
VI. Issues in Contemporary
Islam: Islamism/Radical Islam; Democracy
1. Islam & Modernity
2. Islam & National Identity
3. Democracy, Religious Coexistence &
Secularism
4. Jihad & Radical Islam
Readings: Rahman, Chapter 13 & epilogue.
Mary
Habeck/Knowing
the Enemy: Jihad and Jihadism/Australia-Israel Review December
2006
Bernard
Lewis,
"Freedom and Justice in the Modern Middle East", Foreign Affairs,
May-June 2005, Vol. 84, Issue 3
Texas State University permalink. A valid Texas StateUniversity User Name and password are
required for access.
David
Cook/Understanding Jihad (University of California Press 2005).
David Cook is highly critical of scholars such as John
Esposito, a widely read author on Islam, who, in Cook's view,
"promote the irenic interpretation of jihad." (Cook,
p. 43)
"...Esposito apparently deliberately spirtualizes what is an
unambiguously concrete and militant doctrine (jihad),
without a shred of evidence from the Qur'an or any of the
classical sources, in which the jihad and fighting is against
real human enemies, and not the devil ..." (Cook, p. 42)
See, for example: John
Esposito/Unholy
War: Terror in the Name of Reality (Oxford University Press
2002), pp. 27-28.
Speaking of John Esposito and other Western scholars, David Cook
states in the Afterword of his book Understanding Jihad:
"It is no longer acceptable for Western scholars or Muslim
apologists writing in non-Muslim languages to make flat,
unsupported statements concerning the prevalence - either from a
historical point of view or within contemporary Islam - of the
spiritual jihad. Thus far these writers have offered no
evidence as to whether the spiritual jihad was actually the
primary expression of jihad. It is incumbent upon them,
therefore, first to prove that this doctrine had some type of
reality outside of the Sufi textbooks and second to demonstrate
that either a substantial minority or a majority of Muslims
historically believed and acted upon it or that the spiritual
jihad actually superseded the militant jihad. Thus far no
scholar has accomplished this." (Cook, p. 166)
See also: Bernard Lewis, The Political Language
of Islam (University of Chicago Press 1988/Paper 1991)
@ http://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/P/bo3711632.html
"The sharia is
simply the law, and there is no other. It is holy in that it
derives from God, and it is the external and unchangeable
expression of God's commandments to mankind.
... It is on one of these commandments that the notion of holy
war, in the sense of war ordained by God, is based. The term, so
translated is jihad, an
Arabic word with the literal meaning of 'effort', 'striving,' or
'struggle.' In the Qur'an and still more in the
Traditions, commonly though not invariably followed by the words
'in the path of God', it has usually been understood as meaning
'to wage war.' The great collections of hadith all contain a section
devoted to jihad,
in which the military meaning predominates. The same is true of
the classical manuals of shari'a law. There were some who
argued that jihad
should be understood in a moral and spiritual, rather than a
military, sense. Such arguments were sometimes put forward
by Shi'ite theologians in classical times, and more frequently by
modernizers and reformists in the nineteenth and twentieth
centuries. The overwhelming
majority of classical theologians, jurists, and traditionalists,
however, understood the obligation of jihad in a military sense, and have
examined and expounded it accordingly." (p. 72.)
[boldface added]
For a lengthy description of both classical treatises on jihad and modern
studies based on these sources to which Bernard Lewis refers, see
Bernard Lewis, The Political Language of Islam
pp. 145-147, note 4.
For John L. Esposito's discussion of jihad in his book, What
Everyone Needs to Know about Islam (Oxford University Press
2002), see "What
is
jihad?" (pp. 117 & 118)
in his treatment of "Violence and Terrorists" in Islam as well as
additional remarks elsewhere in his book.
Recommended:
Bernard Lewis, "The Roots Of Muslim Rage", Atlantic
Monthly, September 1990
Texas State University permalink. A valid Texas State University User Name and password
are required for access.
Bernard
Lewis/The
Revolt of Islam/The New Yorker December 19, 2001/reprinted
@aijac.org
Martin
Kramer/Coming To Terms: Fundamentalists Or Islamists?/Middle
East Quarterly/Spring 2003, Vol. X: No.2
Joel
S.
Fetzer, J. Christopher
Soper/Muslims
and the State in Britain, France, and Germany (Cambridge 2005)
Bernard
Lewis/What
Went Wrong? Western Impact & Middle Eastern Response (Oxford
2002)
Max Rodenbeck/The
Truth About Jihad(Review essay on recent books related to
Jihad)/New York Review of Books/August 11 2005 Vol. 52 No. 13
Mark Gould, "Understanding Jihad: An authentic Islamic
tradition", Policy Review, February-March 2005, No. 129.
David
Cook/Anti-Semitic
Themes in Muslim Apocolyptic and Jihadi Literature/Jerusalem
Center for Public Affairs No. 56, May 01, 2007
Robert S. Leiken, "Europe's Angry Muslims", Foreign
Affairs, July-August 2005, Vol. 84, Issue 4.
Texas State University permalink. A valid Texas State University User Name and password
are required for access.
Nina
Bernstein/In
American Cities, No Mirror Image of Muslims of Leeds/NYT/July 21
2005
Tamar
Lewin/Universities
Install Footpaths to Benefit Muslims, and Not Everyone Is
Pleased/NYT August 07, 2007
Neil
MacFarquhar/At
Harvard, Students' Muslim Traditions Are a Topic of Debate/NYT
March 21, 2008
Andrea
Elliott:
An Imam In America- 3 Articles (links)/NYT/March 05 through
March 07, 2006
Andrea
Elliott/A
Cleric's Journey Leads to a Suburban Frontier/NYT January 28,
2007
For critical comments on Andrea Elliott's reporting in
the above
articles, see: Jonathan
Tobin/Another
Pulitzer Prize Disgrace/jewishworldreview.com April 23, 2007
"The most important was Elliot's failure to mention anything
about the role of the Islamic Society of Bay Ridge in the murder
of 16-year-old Ari Halberstam in a van filled with Jewish children
on the Brooklyn Bridge. Not one of her 11,000 words refers to the
fact that it was this same mosque that was the forum for the
sermon that inspired one of its congregants, Rashid Baz, to go out
and try to murder as many Jews as he could in March of 1994.
... How, you may ask, could one write about any religious
institution and ignore the most notorious aspect of its recent
history? ... In a subsequent article in The New York
Sun, Halberstam's mother, Devorah, related that she called Elliot
to ask why she had omitted the story of her son's murder from the
feature on the mosque. Elliot replied that 'she knew nothing about
it.' "
See also: Daniel
Freedman/For Ari Halberstam - Opinion Piece/New York Sun March
8, 2007
Gary
Shapiro/Pulitzer
for Imam Feature Called 'Outrageous'/New York Sun April 20, 2007
Neil MacFarquhar/A Growing Demand for the Rare American Imam/NYT
June 01, 2007
Neil
MacFarquhar/Gay
Muslims Find Freedom, of a Sort, in the U.S./NYT November 7,
2007
Samuel
G.
Freeman/A Hometown Bank Heeds a Call to Serve Its Islamic
Clients/NYT March 7, 2009
University Bank in Ann Arbor, Mich., offers financial products
that comply with Muslim religious law. This past week it recorded
one of its best periods ever.
Neil
MacFarquhar/Iraq's
Shadow Widens Sunni-Shiite Split in U.S./NYT February 04, 2007
Andrea
Elliott/Between
Black and Immmigrant Muslims, an Uneasy Alliance/NYT Sunday,
March 11, 2007
Mark
Landler/German
Judge Cites Koran, Stirring Up Cultural Storm/NYT March 23, 2007
Mark
Landler/After
Lifetime in Germany, Turks Still Alone/NYT March 25, 2007
"Four decades after the first Turks arrived as guest workers,
they are reaching retirement in a land that still feels foreign."
Jane
Perlez/Old
Church Becomes Mosque in Uneasy Britain/NYT/April 02, 2007
"On a chilly night this winter, this pristine town in some of
Britain’s most untouched countryside voted to allow a former
Christian church to become a mosque. ...
The narrow vote by the municipal authorities marked the end of a
bitter struggle by the tiny Muslim population to establish a place
of worship, one that will put a mosque in an imposing stone
Methodist church that had been used as a factory since its
congregation dwindled away 40 years ago."
Mark
Landler/Germans
Split Over a Mosque (in Cologne) and the role of Islam/NYT July
05, 2007
"Plans for what would be one of Germany’s largest mosques are
rattling an ancient city to its foundations."
For a comparative perspective with regard to Cologne and a
Hindu temple and a mosque in the Atlanta area, see:
Brenda
Goodman/In
a Suburb of Atlanta, a Temple Stops Traffic/NYT July 05, 2007
"Sitting like a wedding cake atop a mound of red clay in the suburb
of Lilburn is a Hindu temple that shares an intersection with a
Publix supermarket and a Walgreens pharmacy."
Islam & Democracy
Ian
Buruma/Tariq
Ramadan Has an Identity Issue: Is he an activist scholar or an
extremist in scholarly garb?/NYT Sunday Magazine February 04,
2007
For a critical, highly recommended, review of
this article by Buruma and much more on Western intellectuals and
radical Islam, see:
Paul Berman, "Who's Afraid of Tariq Ramadan?: The
Islamist, the journalist, and the defense of liberalism", The New Republic, June
4, 2007, Vol. 236, No. 4,814, pp. 37-63.
Berman's essay can be directly accessed here
and here.
The Paul Berman essay can also be viewed @ http://www.arnoldleder.com/readings/index.html.
Scroll to the section labeled "Readings on Islam"
and look for "Paul Berman: on Tariq Ramadan". This location is password protected.
Password and user name for access will be provided to students in
the course.
"The equanimity on the part of some
well-known intellectuals and journalists in the face of Islamist
death threats so numerous as to constitute a campaign; the
equanimity in regard to stoning women to death; the journalistic
inability even to acknowledge that women's rights have been at
stake in the debates over Islamism; the inability to recall the
problems faced by Muslim women in European hospitals; the
inability to acknowledge how large has been the role of a revived
anti-Semitism; the striking number of errors of understanding and
even of fact that have entered into the journalistic presentations
of Tariq Ramadan and his ideas; the refusal to discuss with any
frankness the role of Ramadan's family over the years; the
accidental endorsement in the Guardian of the great-uncle
who finds something admirable in the September 11 attacks--what
can possibly account for this string of bumbles, timidities,
gaffes, omissions, miscomprehensions, and slanders?
... Two developments account for it. The first development
is the unimaginable rise of Islamism since the time of the Rushdie
fatwa. The second is terrorism."
See also this critical
review of Tariq Ramadan's writings and views
by Malise Ruthven:
Malise Ruthven, "The Islamic Optimist", The New York Review of Books,
Vol. 54, No. 13, August 16, 2007.
The Malise Ruthven essay can be viewed @ http://www.arnoldleder.com/readings/index.html.
Scroll to the section labeled "Readings on Islam"
and look for "Malise Ruthven: The Islamic Optimist". This location is password protected.
Password and user name for access will be provided to students in
the course.
For another
perspective on Islam and democracy and the views of Tariq Ramadan
and other contemporary Muslim thinkers, see:
Mark
Lilla/The
Politics of God/Sunday Magazine NYT August 19, 2007
"... we must somehow find a way to accept the fact
that, given the immigration policies Western nations have pursued
over the last half-century, they now are hosts to millions of
Muslims who have great difficulty fitting into societies that do
not recognize any political claims based on their divine
revelation. ... the Muslim Shariah is meant to cover the
whole of life, not some arbitrarily demarcated private sphere, and
its legal system has few theological resources for establishing
the independence of politics from detailed divine commands. It is
an unfortunate situation, but we have made our bed, Muslims and
non-Muslims alike. Accommodation and mutual respect can help, as
can clear rules governing areas of tension, like the status of
women, parents’ rights over their children, speech offensive to
religious sensibilities, speech inciting violence, standards of
dress in public institutions and the like. Western countries have
adopted different strategies for coping, some forbidding religious
symbols like the head scarf in schools, others permitting them.
But we need to recognize that coping is the order of the day, not
defending high principle, and that our expectations should remain
low. So long as a sizable population believes in the truth of a
comprehensive political theology, its full reconciliation with
modern liberal democracy cannot be expected.
...
... a number of Muslim thinkers around the world have taken to
promoting a 'liberal' Islam. What they mean is an Islam more
adapted to the demands of modern life, kinder in its treatment of
women and children, more tolerant of other faiths, more open to
dissent. These are brave people who have often suffered for their
efforts, in prison or exile, as did their predecessors in the 19th
century, of which there were many. But now as then, their efforts
have been swept away by deeper theological currents they cannot
master and perhaps do not even understand. The history of
Protestant and Jewish liberal theology reveals the problem: the
more a biblical faith is trimmed to fit the demands of the moment,
the fewer reasons it gives believers for holding on to that faith
in troubled times, when self-appointed guardians of theological
purity offer more radical hope. Worse still, when such a faith is
used to bestow theological sanctification on a single form of
political life — even an attractive one like liberal democracy —
the more it will be seen as collaborating with injustice when that
political system fails. The dynamics of political theology seem to
dictate that when liberalizing reformers try to conform to the
present, they inspire a countervailing and far more passionate
longing for redemption in the messianic future. That is what
happened in Weimar Germany and is happening again in contemporary
Islam.
The complacent liberalism and revolutionary messianism we’ve
encountered are not the only theological options. There is another
kind of transformation possible in biblical faiths, and that is
the renewal of traditional political theology from within. If
liberalizers are apologists for religion at the court of modern
life, renovators stand firmly within their faith and reinterpret
political theology so believers can adapt without feeling
themselves to be apostates. ...
Today, a few voices are calling for just this kind of
renewal of Islamic political theology. Some, like Khaled Abou El
Fadl, a law professor at the University of California, Los
Angeles, challenge the authority of today’s puritans, who make
categorical judgments based on a literal reading of scattered
Koranic verses. In Abou El Fadl’s view, traditional Islamic law
can still be applied to present-day situations because it brings
a subtle interpretation of the whole text to bear on particular
problems in varied circumstances. Others, like the Swiss-born
cleric and professor Tariq Ramadan, are public figures whose
writings show Western Muslims that their political theology,
properly interpreted, offers guidance for living with confidence
in their faith and gaining acceptance in what he calls an alien
'abode.' To read their works is to be reminded what a risky
venture renewal is. It can invite believers to participate more
fully and wisely in the political present, as the Protestant
Reformation eventually did; it can also foster dreams of
returning to a more primitive faith, through violence if
necessary, as happened in the Wars of Religion.
Perhaps for this reason, Abou El Fadl and especially Ramadan
have become objects of intense and sometimes harsh scrutiny by
Western intellectuals. We prefer speaking with the Islamic
liberalizers because they share our language: they accept the
intellectual presuppositions of the Great Separation and simply
want maximum room given for religious and cultural expression.
They do not practice political theology. But the prospects of
enduring political change through renewal are probably much
greater than through liberalization. By speaking from within the
community of the faithful, renovators give believers compelling
theological reasons for accepting new ways as authentic
reinterpretations of the faith. Figures like Abou El Fadl and
Ramadan speak a strange tongue, even when promoting changes we
find worthy; their reasons are not our reasons. ...
... We have little reason to expect societies in the grip of
a powerful political theology to follow our unusual path, which
was opened up by a unique crisis within Christian civilization.
This does not mean that those societies necessarily lack the
wherewithal to create a decent and workable political order; it
does mean that they will have to find the theological resources
within their own traditions to make it happen."
For a detailed examination of
"the Islamic foundations for affirming on principled grounds
residence, political obligation, and loyalty to a non-Muslim
state" and, in the author's view, evidence for the existence of
"firm and culturally authentic Islamic values ... which can ground
Islamically a social contract between Muslims and a non-Muslim
liberal democracy", see:
Andrew F. March,
"Islamic Foundations for a Social Contract in non-Muslim Liberal
Democracies", American Political Science Review, Vol. 101, No. 2, pp. 235-251, May
2007.
This article by Andrew March can be accessed @
http://www.arnoldleder.com/readings/index.html.
Scroll to the section labeled "Readings on Islam"
and look for "Andrew March: Islam in non-Muslim
Liberal Democracies". This location is
password protected. Password and user name for access will
be provided to students in the course.
This article by Andrew March can be directly accessed @ this
location (pdf).
See also: Mark
Gould/Islam,
the Law, and The Sovereignty of God: Accomodating Qur'anic
principles to the civil religion/Policy Review, June-July 2008
"... the absorption of Muslim communities into liberal
democracies may facilitate the transformation of Islamic norms
into principles consistent with constitutionalism.
...
Where Muslims cannot expect to enforce Shari’a
they will, hopefully, work to accommodate Islam to the civil
religion we find, for example, in the United States. In this civil
religion, moral precepts from many denominations are found, but
they are abstracted from the denominational precepts that may be
in force for believers, precepts that are not enforced
politically. The resources for such an accommodation can be found
in Islam, in its concern for equality and social justice. If this
accommodation occurs in the United States, perhaps it will have an
effect on the larger umma, spurring
an understanding of Islam that will enable its development in a
way to facilitate the construction of viable constitutional states
in Muslim majority countries".
Christopher
Caldwell/Reflections
On The Revolution In Europe: Immigration, Islam, And The West
(Doubleday 2009)
See these reviews of this book: Dwight
Garner/A Turning Tide in
Europe as Islam Gains Ground/NYT July 30, 2009
and Fouad
Ajami/Strangers in the Land (w/photo) NYT Sunday Book Review,
August 2, 2009.
For a perspective very different from that of Christopher
Caldwell on Muslims in Western Europe, see: Carolyn
M.
Warner, Manfred W. Wenner/Religion and the Political
Organization of Muslims in Europe, Perspectives on Politics,
Volume 4, Number 3 (September 2006), pp. 457-479. (pdf) Note: This is a Texas State University Library
permalink. A valid Texas State
University User Name and password are required to access this
article.
Joel
S.
Fetzer, J. Christopher Soper/Muslims and the State in Britain,
France, and Germany (Cambridge 2005)
"It is absurd to think that Islam
cannot accommodate democracy or that democracy cannot accommodate
Islam. It is not Islam per se, but religion tout court that stands
in some tension with secularism and with democracy – a tension
that is healthy rather than unhealthy in a free society. Like
Christianity and other religions, Islam is a religion practiced in
many cultures and societies, sectarian, stratified, schismatic and
pluralistic. To the degree Islam is fundamentalist, so is religion
in many places, because in our secular age religion is under siege
and fundamentalism is above all a reaction to religion under
siege".
Tamara Cofman Wittes/Islamist Political Parties: Three Kinds of Movements,
Journal of Democracy, Vol. 19, No. 3, July 2008 (pdf)
See also: Tamara
Cofman
Wittes/Categories of Islamism/Middle East Strategy at Harvard
(MESH), July 30, 2008
Bassam
Tibi/Islamists Approach Europe: Turkey's Islamist Danger/Middle
East Quarterly, Winter 2009, pp.47-54.
"Since their electoral landslide victory in November 2002,
Islamists within Turkey's Justice and Development Party (Adalet ve
Kalkınma Partisi, AKP) have camouflaged themselves as
"democratic Islamic conservatives."[1] The AKP claims to be the
Muslim equivalent of the Christian-Democratic parties of Western
Europe. Such an analogy is false, however. What the AKP seeks is
not "Islam without fear," to borrow the phrase of Trinity College
professor Raymond Baker,[2] but rather a strategy for a creeping
Islamization that culminates in a Shari‘a (Islamic law) state not
compatible with a secular, democratic order. The AKP does not
advertise this agenda and often denies it. This did not convince
the chief prosecutor of Turkey who, because of AKP efforts to
Islamize Turkey, sought to ban the party and seventy-one of its
leaders. While the AKP survived a ban, the majority of justices
found that the AKP had worked to advance an Islamist agenda and
undermine secularism.[3] Nevertheless, the AKP enjoys the backing
of the United States and the European Union as well. Through its
support for institutional Islamism in Turkey, the West loses its
true friends: liberal Muslims."
See all of Olivier
Roy, Globalized Islam: The Search For A New Ummah (Columbia
University Press 2004 & 2006) and note Chapter
4
The Triumph Of The Religious
Self - pp. 148 - 201 especially The Crisis Of Authority and
religious Knowledge - pp. 158 -171.
Religious Coexistence -
Muslims and Jews Under Islamic Rule:
S.
D.
Goitein/The Actual and Legal
Position of the Jews Under Arab Islam-Excerpt from
Chapter 5 of S.
D.
Goitein, Jews And Arabs:Their Contacts Through the Ages
(Schocken, 1974 revised edition; original published in 1955).
Excerpt:
"... it is certain that the Muslim conquest meant for the Jews a
great improvement in their situation in various respects: first,
they ceased to be an outcast community persecuted by the ruling
church and became part of a vast class of subjects with a special
status, Muslim public law made no distinction between Jews and
Christians; secondly, the actual provisions which regulated the
legal status of so large a part of the population were by the very
force of circumstance less oppressive than those intended by the
Byzantine rulers especially for the Jews; ...
...
However, in the second, and in particular the third century of the
Muslim era, when, for many reasons, the Muslims had become the
majority and had developed an elaborate religious law, many
humiliating restrictions were imposed upon Christians and Jews,
some of which went back directly to Byzantine anti-Jewish
legislation. First, infidels were forced to dress
differently from Muslims. This injunction gave rise throughout the
centuries to a spate of often ridiculous laws; for example, some
rules forced Jewish women to wear shoes of different colors, one
black and the other white. The
yellow badge for Jews was known in Muslim countries many
centuries before it was introduced into Christian Europe."
(boldface added - This statement by Goitein, boldfaced
here, is found on page 67 of the 1955 edition.)
On the yellow badge for Jews: "Christians and
Jews were to wear distinguishing garments, or emblems on their
clothes. This was the origin of the *ghiyār, the yellow
patch which was first introduced by a caliph in Baghdad in the
ninth century, and spread into Europe - for Jews - in later
medieval times." Bernard
Lewis/The
Multiple Identities Of The Middle East (Schocken Books 1998),
pp. 120-121.
*ghiyār
- "differentiation", regulation of dress for tolerated
minorities such as Jews and Christians. See: Josef W.
Meri, Jere L. Bacharach/Medieval Islamic Civilization (Routledge
2005), p. 160.
See also: Norman A.
Stillman/The Jews Of Arab Lands: A History and Source Book (The
Jewish Publication Society of America 1979)
Chapter
2
- Under The New Order: Middle-Eastern Jewry in the First Three
Centuries of Islam (pp. 22-39.)
See especially pages 24,
25,
26,
and 27;
and also
Bernard
Lewis/The
Jews of Islam (Princeton University Press 1984).
For a comparative analysis of the position of Jews in Islam and
in Christianity during the Middle Ages, where the author notes the
"substantial security - at times verging on social (though not
legal) parity) - that Jews enjoyed through centuries of existence
under Muslim rule", see:
Mark
R.
Cohen/Under Crescent & Cross: The Jews in the Middle Ages
(Princeton University Press 1994 and 2008)
Mark
R. Cohen, Under Crescent & Cross, Introduction to the 2008 Edition
"UNDER CRESCENT AND CROSS was published in 1994. It was a
response to a polarization that had occurred, especially since the
1970s, in historical writing about Jewish-Muslim relations in the
Middle Ages. At one pole stood those who adhered to the view,
first espoused by European Jewish historians in the nineteenth
century, that relations between Jews and Arabs were more
harmonious than the so-called lachrymose relations between Jews
and Christians in Europe.This was exaggerated by some into the
idea of an interfaith utopia, a veritable “Golden Age,” with
Muslim Andalusia as the model. According to this view, Jews lived
securely, protected by a tolerant Islam, and achieved remarkable
heights in medicine and in the political arena, holding prominent
positions in Muslim courts and becoming assimilated culturally to
Arab-Muslim intellectual society.
The literary achievement of the Jews of Andalusia and other parts
of the Islamic world—the starting point for the “Golden Age”
idea—cannot be denied, nor is it denied by Jewish scholars. Even
the political application, however exaggerated, has a certain
objective correlative, for some Jews did, indeed,achieve
remarkable heights in official Islamic society.There is even a
connection between the cultural and the political achievements. It
is reasonable to assume that a second-class minority thoroughly
adopts the culture of the majority group only if it enjoys a
certain measure of comfort in society as a whole, let alone has
access to intellectual circles in the majority society and to its
corridors of power. But the interfaith utopia was a myth insofar
as it ignored the Jews’ inferior legal status and the fierce
persecution of non-Muslims (Jews and Christians) in North Africa
and Andalusia in the twelfth century by the infamous
“fundamentalist”Almohads, and other occasional outbursts of
hostility and violence in Spain and elsewhere in the Islamic
world.
These painful moments in Jewish-Arab history were also disregarded
by Arab and Arabist writers in more recent times.They adopted the
originally Jewish myth of the interfaith utopia and argued that
relations between Jews and Muslims had been harmonious until the
coming of Zionism. Absent Zionism, they asserted, the Arab-Israeli
conflict would disappear. Some even suggested that Israelis give
up their state and return to living under the benevolent
protection of a tolerant Islam.
The Jewish response to these claims—the opposite pole—represented
a drastic, 180-degree turn away from the Jewish image of the
interfaith utopia. Jewish writers, some of them historians, most
of them nonspecialist popular writers, journalists, or blog
masters, put forth the claim that Islam has been an intolerant
religion from the very beginning, and that throughout the Middle
Ages Islam persecuted Jews, treating them almost as poorly as they
were treated by antisemitic, medieval Christianity. At its
extreme, the revisionist theory brands Islam as an inherently
antisemitic religion and blames Islam at its core, not Zionism,
for the current conflict between Jews and Arabs. I have called
this, alternatively, the “countermyth of Islamic persecution” and
the “neolachrymose conception of Jewish-Arab history.” It ignores,
one might say suppresses, the substantial security—at times
verging on social (though not legal) parity—that Jews enjoyed
through centuries of existence under Muslim rule, as well as the
deeply Arabized culture of the Jews of the Islamic Middle Ages."
See this chapter in Mark R. Cohen's book: Mark
R.
Cohen, Under Crescent & Cross, Chapter Four-The Legal Position Of Jews In
Islam, pp. 52 through 74.
Religious Coexistence in
Islamic Spain: Enlightened Tolerance or Distorted Utopian Image:
Edward
Rothstein/Was
the Islam Of Old Spain Truly Tolerant?/NYT September 27, 2003
"... a retrospective utopianism. Islamic Spain has been hailed
for its ''convivencia'' -- its spirit of tolerance in which Jews,
Christians and Muslims, created a premodern renaissance. Córdoba,
in the 10th century, was a center of commerce and scholarship.
Arabic was a conduit between classical knowledge and nascent
Western science and philosophy. The ecumenical Andalusian spirit
was even invoked at this summer's opening ceremony for the new
mosque. ...
... That heritage, though, can be difficult to define. Even at the
mosque, the facade of liberality gave way: at its conference on
''Islam in Europe,'' one speaker praised al-Andalus not for its
openness but for its rigorous fundamentalism. Were similar views
also part of the Andalusian past? The impulse to idealize runs
strong. If Andalusia really had been an enlightened society that
combined religious belief with humanism and artistry, then it
would provide an extraordinary model, offering proof of Islamic
possibilities now eclipsed, while spurring new understandings of
the West. ...
... A more scholarly paean is offered in The Ornament of the World: How
Muslims, Jews and Christians Created a Culture of Tolerance in
Medieval Spain (Little, Brown, 2002) by Maria Rosa
Menocal, a professor of Spanish and Portuguese at Yale University.
Ms. Menocal argues that Andalusia's culture was ''rooted in
pluralism and shaped by religious tolerance,'' particularly in its
prime -- a period that lasted from the mid-eighth century until
the fall of the Umayyad dynasty in 1031. It was undermined, she
argues, by fundamentalism -- Catholic and Islamic alike.
... But as many scholars have argued, this image is distorted.
Even the Umayyad dynasty, begun by Abd al-Rahman in 756, was far
from enlightened. Issues of succession were often settled by
force. One ruler murdered two sons and two brothers. Uprisings in
805 and 818 in Córdoba were answered with mass executions and the
destruction of one of the city's suburbs. Wars were accompanied by
plunder, kidnappings and ransom. Córdoba itself was finally sacked
by Muslim Berbers in 1013, its epochal library destroyed.
... Andalusian governance was also based on a religious tribal
model. Christians and Jews, who shared Islam's Abrahamic past, had
the status of dhimmis -- alien minorities. They rose high but
remained second-class citizens; one 11th-century legal text called
them members of ''the devil's party.'' They were subject to
special taxes and, often, dress codes. Violence also erupted,
including a massacre of thousands of Jews in Grenada in 1066 and
the forced exile of many Christians in 1126."
For another view of the Jewish and Christian experiences in
Islamic Spain, see: Darío
Fernández-Morera/The
Myth of the Andalusian Paradise/Intercollegiate
Review,Vol.
41, No. 2, Fall 2006 (pdf).
See
also:
Dario Fernandez-Morera, The
Myth of the Andalusian Paradise: Muslims, Christians, and
Jews under Islamic Rule in Medieval Spain
(Intercollegiate Studies Institute, February 2016)
http://www.amazon.com/The-Myth-Andalusian-Paradise-Christians/dp/1610170954.
For an analysis of Christian - Muslim
relations and problems of religious and cultural identity in
al-Andalus or Spain under Islamic rule (with a focus on the ninth
century), see:
Jessica
A. Coope/The Martyrs of Córdoba: Community And Family Conflict
In An Age Of Mass Conversion (University of Nebraska Press 1995).
See especially: Jessica A. Coope, The Martyrs of Córdoba,
Chapter 6 - Problems of
Religious and Cultural Identity.
See also: Rachel
Donaldo/Name
Debate Echoes an Old Clash of Faiths [Cordoba, Spain] (w/photos
& links)/NYT November 5, 2010
The bishop of an ancient cathedral objects to signs that reflect
its origin as a mosque, in the latest chapter in the region’s
contested religious legacy.
Jews Under Shi'a Rule in Iran:
Robert
S.
Greenberger, "How Jew-Friendly Persia Became Anti-Semitic Iran",
Moment Magazine, November-December 2006
A Texas State University permalink. A Texas State
University User Name and password are required for access. (Note: This link may
provide direct access without going through the Texas Stsate
University library.)
"... Treatment of minorities (in Persia/Iran) deteriorated
after the Safavids took power in the 1500s, imposing their
hard-line brand of Shia Islam and ushering in “the worst era of
Persian-Jewish relations,” says political scientist Eliz
Sanasarian of the University of Southern California, author of
Religious Minorities in Iran.
The Safavids forcibly converted Iran’s Sunni Muslims to Shia
Islam and introduced the
concept of 'ritual pollution,' which further segregated
minorities from their neighbors. Because nonbelievers were
deemed spiritually and physically contagious, Jews were barred
from leaving their houses when it rained, for fear the water
would transmit their impurities. A Jew who entered a Muslim
home had to sit on a special rug and could not be offered tea,
food or a water pipe, since any object touched by a Jew could
no longer be used by a Muslim. (boldface added)
Safavid rule came to an end in 1736, but the Muslim perception
of Jews as impure remained. Occasional violent outbreaks,
reminiscent of the blood libels and pogroms carried out in Europe,
punctuated the next two centuries of Qajar Dynasty rule. In
one incident in the northeastern town of Mashhad in 1839, an
ailing Jewish woman was told to use dogs’ blood to cure a certain
malady. A rumor quickly spread that she had tried the cure on a
Shia holiday, deliberately insulting the sect. Jews were attacked
and some three dozen killed, while the rest of the Jewish
community was given the choice of conversion to Islam or death.
Such bloody outbreaks persisted until the 20th century, ..."
Religious Coexistence - Muslims and Christians in Egypt
Michael
Slackman/As
Tensions Rise for Egypt's Christians, Officials Call Clashes
Secular/NYT August 2, 2008
A rash of violence that has been described as “open season” on the
nation’s Christians is actually a series of unrelated incidents,
according to security officials.
"Christian Arabs have increasingly complained of being
marginalized in the Middle East, with large numbers leaving over
the decades. Now it appears that pressure on these communities is
spiking, whether in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan or the West Bank.
In each, Christians speak of specific national behavior that has
made them feel less welcome."
Michael
Slackman/In
Egypt, Religious Clashes Are Off the Record/NYT February 1, 2010
During one of the most serious outbreaks of sectarian violence
in years, Egypt declared that any talk of sectarian conflict
amounted to sedition.
Ethnic & Racial Relations in
the Islamic Experience
Bernard
Lewis/Race
and Slavery in the Middle East: An Historical Enquiry
w/reproductions of illustrated artwork (Oxford University
Press 1990)
"... in the writings of Muslim jurists, who unanimously reject the
enslavement of free Muslims, of whatever race or origin. Nor
did the total identification of blackness with slavery, which
occurred in North and South America, ever take place in the Muslim
world. There were always white slaves as well as black ones,
and free blacks as well as slaves. Nevertheless, the
identification of blackness with certain forms of slavery went
very far - and in later centuries white slaves grew increasingly
rare.
...
In the central Islamic lands, black slaves were most commonly used
for domestic and menial purposes, often as eunuchs, sometimes also
in economic enterprises, as, for example, in the gold mines of ...
Upper Egypt ..., in the salt mines, and in the copper mines of the
Sahara where both male and female slaves were employed. The
most famous were the black slave
gangs who toiled in the salt flats of Basra. Their
task was to remove and stack the nitrous topsoil, so as to clear
the undersoil for cultivation, probably of sugar, and at the same
time to extract the saltpeter. Consisting principally of
slaves imported from East Africa and numbering some tens of
thousands, they lived and worked in conditions of extreme
misery. ... They
rose in several successive rebellions, the most important of
which lasted fifteen years, from 868 to 883, and for a while
offered a serious threat to the Baghdad Caliphate. (boldface
added)
Jurists occasionally discuss the status of black Muslim
slaves. Muslim law unequivocally forbids the enslavement of
free Muslims of whatever race, and was usually obeyed in
this. There is, however, evidence that the law was not
always strictly enforced to protect Muslim captives from black
Africa."
(Bernard Lewis, Race
and Slavery in the Middle East, pp.
55-57; for a description of the sources
consulted by Lewis on the slave
revolt of the Zanj, as it has come to be known, see
Lewis, p. 127, note 18.) (boldface added)
Note: The term
"zenci" in Turkish (pronounced zenji) remains in modern
colloquial Turkish a term used to refer to individuals
with black skin. See: New Redhouse Turkish-English Dictionary
(Redhouse Yayınevi, 1968).
For an example of contemporary perceptions of race and
ethnicity in Saudi Arabia, see:
Robert
F.
Worth/A Black Imam Breaks Ground in Mecca (w/photo)/NYT April
11. 2009
Sheik Adil Kalbani became the first black man to lead prayers
in Mecca after being chosen by King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia.
"Officially, it was his skill at reciting the Koran that won him
the position, which he carries out — like the Grand Mosque’s eight
other prayer leaders — only during the holy month of Ramadan. But
the racial significance of the king’s gesture was unmistakable.
Sheik Adil, like most Saudis, is quick to caution that any racism
here is not the fault of Islam, which preaches
egalitarianism. The Prophet Muhammad himself, who founded
the religion here 1,400 years ago, had black companions.
“Our Islamic history has so many famous black people,” said the
imam, as he sat leaning his arm on a cushion in the reception room
of his home. 'It is not like the West.'
It is also true that Saudi Arabia is far more ethnically diverse
than most Westerners realize. Saudis with Malaysian or African
features are a common sight along the kingdom’s west coast, the
descendants of pilgrims who came here over the centuries and ended
up staying.
But slavery was practiced here
too, and was abolished only in 1962*. Many traditional Arabs
from Nejd, the central Saudi heartland, used to refer to all
outsiders as “tarsh al bahr” — vomit from the sea. People of
African descent still face some discrimination, as do most
immigrants, even from other Arab countries. Many Saudis complain
that the kingdom is still far too dominated by Nejd, the homeland
of the royal family. There are nonracial forms of discrimination
too, and many Shiite Muslims, a substantial minority, say they are
not treated fairly. (boldface added)
'The prophet told us that social classes will remain, because of
human nature,' Sheik Adil said gravely. 'These are part of the
pre-Islamic practices that persist'.”
*For a reference to the abolition of slavery in Saudi Arabia in
1962, see: Bernard
Lewis/The
Multiple Identities Of The Middle East (Schocken Books 1998),
p. 40.
For a report on the contemporary status of Iraqis of
African descent, see:
Timothy
Williams/In
Iraq's African Enclave, Color Is Plainly Seen (w/photos &
links)/NYT December 3, 2009
African-Iraqis talk of discrimination so steeped in Iraqi
culture that they are prohibited from interracial marriage and
denied even menial jobs.
"Officially, Iraq is a colorblind society that in the tradition of
Prophet Muhammad treats black people with equality and respect.
But on the packed dirt streets of Zubayr, Iraq’s scaled-down
version of Harlem, African-Iraqis
talk of discrimination so steeped in Iraqi culture that they are
commonly referred to as 'abd' — slave in Arabic — prohibited
from interracial marriage and denied even menial jobs. (boldface
added)
Historians say that most African-Iraqis arrived as slaves from
East Africa as part of the Arab slave trade starting about 1,400
years ago. They worked in southern Iraq’s salt marshes and sugar
cane fields."
Additional Materials on Islam
and Democracy:
Jon Emontjan, "As Shariah Experiment Becomes a
Model, Indonesia’s Secular Face Slips", NYT, January 13, 2017 @
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/12/world/asia/indonesia-sharia-law-aceh.html?ref=world&_r=0
Calvin
Sims/Indonesia:
Gambling That Tolerance Will Trump Fear/NYT Sunday Week in
Review April 15, 2007
Photo:
In
Banda Aceh, Indonesia, women are caned under local Islamic
law/NYT April 15, 2007
See: Calvin
Sims/Indonesia:
Gambling That Tolerance Will Trump Fear/NYT April 15, 2007
Peter
Gelling/Indonesian
Village Struggles With Ban on Muslim Sect/NYT, June 11, 2008
A day after Indonesia issued a decree calling on 200,000 adherents
of a 130-year-old Muslim sect to cease practicing their faith or
face arrest, the country braced for protests.
Islam in Malaysia: Liz
Gooch/A
Reality Show Where Islam Is the Biggest Star (w/photos)/NYT July
29, 2010
A show in which contestants compete for a job offer as an imam
has built a following among young Malaysians.
Liz
Gooch/In
Malaysia, Shiites Struggle to Practice Their Faith/NYT March 24,
2011
Where Sunni Islam is the official religion, other
forms of the faith, including Shiite Islam, are considered deviant
and are not allowed to be spread.
... "The Constitution guarantees freedom of religion, but when it
comes to Islam, the country’s official religion, only the Sunni
denomination is permitted. Other forms, including Shiite Islam,
are considered deviant and are not allowed to be spread."
... While sectarian divisions are associated more with countries
like Iraq and Pakistan, Islamic experts say Malaysia is an example
of a Muslim-majority country where the Shiite branch is banned.
They say the recent raid reflects the religious authorities’
reluctance to accept diversity within Islam, and was part of the
authorities’ continuing efforts to impose a rigid interpretation
of the religion."
Craig
S.
Smith/North Africa: Under Attack, and Relying on Repression/NYT
Sunday Week in Review April 15, 2007
James Traub of the NYT provides an
informative, and, on occasion, cautiously accepting or
sympathetic look at the activities of the Muslim Botherhood in
Egypt in recent years in the context of the larger question of
"Islamic democrats". He concludes with the suggestion that
America engage the Muslim Brotherhood as a "moderate Islamic
body". See: James
Traub/Islamic
Democrats?/NYT sunday Magazine April 29, 2007.
For a very different view of the compatibility of Islam and
democracy, see:
David
Bukay/Can There Be an Islamic Democracy?/Middle East Quarterly
Spring 2007, Vol. XIV, No. 2.
"Are Islam and democracy compatible? ... Many Muslim
intellectuals seek to prove that Islam enshrines democratic
values. ... For Islamists, though, the motivation is to
remove suspicion about the nature and goals of Islamic movements
such as the Muslim Brotherhood ... ."
Thanassis
Cambanis/Jordan's
Islamists Seek Offices Their Allies Scorn/NYT November 16, 2007
Sabrina
Tavernise/Turkish
City (Konya) Counters Fear of Islam's Reach/NYT May 15, 2007
Sabrina
Tavernise/A
Secular Turkish City Feels Islam's Pulse Beating Stronger,
Causing Divisions/NYT June 01, 2007
Sabrina
Tavernise/In
Turkey, Bitter Feud Has Roots In History/NYT June 22, 2008
Michael
Slackman/Molding
the Ideal Islamic Citizen (Iran)/NYT-Week in Review/Sunday,
September 09, 2007
Michael
Slackman/Arrests
in Egypt Point Toward a Crackdown/NYT June 15, 2007
"The authorities have been referring to the family as Koranists, a
derogatory label in the context of the faith, suggesting
allegiance to a cultlike organization."
Michael
Slackman/Memo
From Egypt: Fashion and Faith Meet, on Foreheads of the
Pious/NYT December 18, 2007
It has become popular among men to have a circle of callused skin
on the forehead, which emerges when worshipers press their heads
to the ground for prayer.
Michael
Slackman/With
a Word, Eygptians Leave It All to Fate/NYT June 20, 2008
Nazila
Fathi/Despite
President's Denials, Gays Insist They Exist, if Quietly, in
Iran/NYT/September 30, 2007
Islam and Science:
Pervez
Amirali
Hoodbhoy/Science and the Islamic World-The quest for
rapproachment/Physics Today, Vol. 60, August, 2007
Pervez Amirali Hoodbhoy, chair and professor in the department of
physics at Quaid-i-Azam University in Islamabad, Pakistan, in his
article in Physics
Today, the flagship publication of The American Institute of Physics,
contends: "Internal causes led to the decline of Islam's
scientific greatness long before the era of mercantile
imperialism. To contribute once again, Muslims must be
introspective and ask what went wrong."
From the article by Pervez Amirali Hoodbhoy:
Image
of
16th Century Muslim Astronomers: Ottoman Empire astronomers
working in 1577 at an observatory in Istanbul
This painting accompanied an epic poem that honored
Sultan Murad III, who ruled from 1574 to 1595. The observatory
was demolished in 1580 after astronomers sighted a comet and
predicted a military victory that failed to materialize. The
poem was published a year later. (For more on
ancient Islamic astronomy, see the American Institute of Physics
online cosmology exhibit @ http://www.aip.org/history/cosmology/tools/tools-nakedeyes.htm#astrolabe.)
See also: Dennis
Overbye/How
Islam Won, and Lost, the Lead in Science/NYT October 30, 2001.
For a discussion of the efforts of early Islamic thinkers
to examine the relationship between Islamic theology and science,
as it was understood in their day, see:
Josef
Van Ess/The Flowering of Muslim Theology (Harvard University
Press 2006) pp. 79-98 (a
portion) of Chapter 3 Theology
and
Science.
Additional Recommended Readings (various):
Christopher
Caldwell/Allah
Mode: France's Islam Problem/The Weekly Standard/July 15, 2002
Christopher
Caldwell/Veiled
Threat: Can French Secularism Survive Islam?/The Weekly
Standard/Jan. 19, 2004
Katrin
Bennhold/Spurning
Secularism, Many French Muslims Find Haven in Catholic Schools
(includes photos)/NYT September 30, 2008
Spurning the secular state schools, some Muslim students have
found religious accommodation at private ones.
Neil J.Kressel, "The Urgent Need to Study Islamic
Anti-Semitism", The Chronicle Of Higher Education, March12,
2004, Vol. 50. Issue 27.
Texas State University permalink. A valid Texas State University User Name and password
are required for access.
Robert
F.
Worth/Languishing at the Bottom of Yemen's Ladder (with slide
show)/NYT February 27, 2008
"They are known as 'Al Akhdam' — the servants. Set apart by their African features
(see photo),
they form a kind of hereditary caste at the very bottom of Yemen’s
social ladder". (boldface added)
Bruce
Bawer/Tolerating
Intolerance: The Challenge of Fundamentalist Islam in Western
Europe/Partisan Review/July19, 2002
Bernard
Lewis/Muslim Anti-Semitism/The MiddleEast Quarterly/June 1998
V. S.
Naipaul/Our Universal Civilization/The 1990 Wriston
Lecture/manhattan-institute.org/html/wl1990.htm
Hesham
Samy Abdel-Alim/Hip hop Islam/Weekly.Al-Ahram/7-13 July 2005
Adam
Nossiter/Senegal
Court Forbids Forcing Children to Beg (w/photo & link to a
Human Rights Watch report)/NYT September 13, 2010
Some see a social revolution in the punishment of Muslim holy
men who lived off the gleanings of the young panhandlers they
coerced.
VII. Women & Gender
in Islam
1. Contested Memory: Sunni-Shi'a Perspectives
& the Figure of Aishe
2. Sexuality & Women's Rights
3. Muslim Gays
Photo:
In
Banda Aceh, Indonesia, women are caned under local Islamic
law/NYT April 15, 2007
See: Calvin
Sims/Indonesia:
Gambling That Tolerance Will Trump Fear/NYT April 15, 2007
Rasheed
Abou-Alsamh/Ruling
Jolts Even Saudis: 200 Lashes for Rape Victim/NYT November 16,
2007
Rasheed
Abou-Alsamh/Saudi
Rape Case Spurs Calls for Reform/NYT December 1, 2007
"The case of a 20-year-old woman who was sentenced to be lashed
after pressing charges against seven men who raped her and a male
companion has provoked a rare and angry public debate in Saudi
Arabia, leading to renewed calls for reform of the Saudi judicial
system.
... The woman, known here only as “the Qatif girl, ” was
initially subjected to 90 lashes for being alone with a man to
whom she was not married.
... Her outspoken human rights lawyer appealed the sentence
and brought down the wrath of the court, which doubled the woman’s
sentence and stripped her lawyer of his license to practice."
Robert
Mackey/The
Lede: Saudis Debate Ban on Women Drivers (w/links to
blog & youtube)/NYT May 7, 2009
Katherine
Zoepf/Talk
of
Women’s Rights Divides Saudi Arabia/NYT May 31, 2010
Katherine
Zoepf/For
Saudi Women, Biggest Challenge Is Getting to Play (w/links &
photo)/NYT November 20, 2010
Physical activity is forbidden in Saudi Arabia’s state-run
girls’ schools, and the country is one of the few that have not
sent women to the Olympic Games.
... "The laws and customs that govern Saudi women’s lives are
among the most restrictive anywhere. Public separation of the
sexes is stringent. Saudi women may not drive or vote and must
wear floor-length cloaks known as abayas and head scarves whenever
they leave home. They may not appear in court."
Salman
Massod/Video
of Taliban Flogging (of a woman) Rattles Pakistan (w/video)/NYT
April 4, 2009
An undated image taken from mobile phone footage released by Dunya
TV Channel shows a woman in a body-covering burka face down on the
ground being flogged.
Paying no heed, the commander orders those holding her to tighten
their grip and continues the public flogging. A large group of men
quietly stands and watches in a circle around her.
See also: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/apr/02/taliban-pakistan-justice-women-flogging.
Note
on video: Access to this video requires use of more recent
browsers.
Barry
Bearak/In
a Complex Family, Death Adds to the Indignity (Polygamy &
Muslim Women in South Africa)/NYT July 23, 2009
A South African court ruled that when a husband dies without a
will in a polygamous Muslim marriage, each of his wives is
guaranteed legal rights of inheritance.
Steven
Erlanger
and Souad Mekhennet/Family Code Gets Nudge, but Women Seek a
Push (Morocco)/NYT August 19, 2009
Five years after changes were passed to family law in Morocco,
conservatives are still angry, and young women are still falling
through the cracks.
Neil
MacFarquhar/Abused
Muslim Women in U.S. Gain Advocates/NYT January 6, 2008
Sara
Corbett/A
Cutting Tradition (w/slides)/NYT Sunday Magazine January 20,
2008
Robert
F.
Worth/Voice for Abused Women Upsets Dubai Patriarchy/NYT March
23, 2008
Sharla Musabih, an American-born Emirati citizen, has founded the
Emirates’ first women’s shelter and earned many enemies in the
process.
Steven
Erlanger/A
Daughter of France's 'Lost Territories' Fights for Them/NYT June
14, 2008
Fadela Amara, one of the highest-ranking Muslim women in France,
is responsible for bringing hope to the poor, angry suburbs that
burst into flames three years ago.
Katrin
Bennhold/A
Veil Closes France's Door to Citizenship/NYT July 19, 2008
Steven
Erlanger/Burqa
Furor Scrambles French Politics (w/photos)/NYT September 1, 2009
A fear that France’s principles of citizens’ rights, equality and
secularism are being undermined is shaping the debate over whether
to ban any face-covering cloak.
Photo for this NYT article by Steven Erlanger: A
woman wearing a niqab passed a bookstore at the annual meeting
of the Islamic Organizations Union in Le Bourget, in the
northeastern suburbs of Paris in 2005.
Elaine
Sciolino
and Souad Mekhennet/Operation Lets Muslim Women Reclaim
Virginity (Europe)/NYT, June 11, 2008
Readings:
Fatima
Mernissi/Beyond
the Veil: Male Female Dynamics in Modern Muslim Society
((Indiana University Press Revised Edition 1987, 1st Edition
1975) Read the entire book.
From the Publisher:
"... Mernissi explores the disorienting effects of modern life
on male-female relations, looks at the male-female unit as a basic
element of the structure of the Muslim system, and explores the
sexual dynamicxs of the Muslim world."
Read Aslan, pp. 68-74.
Recommended:
Leila
Ahmed/Women
and Gender in Islam: Historical Roots of a Modern Debate (Yale
University Press 1992)
From the Publisher:
"Are Islamic societies inherently oppressive to women? Is the
trend among Islamic women to appear once again in veils and other
traditional clothing a symbol of regression or an effort to return
to a 'pure' Islam that was just and fair to both sexes? In this
book Leila Ahmed adds a new perspective to the current debate
about women and Islam by exploring its historical roots, tracing
the developments in Islamic discourses on women and gender from
the ancient world to the present."
Reuben
Levy,
The Social Structure of Islam, Chapter II (pp. 91 through 134) -
The Status Of Women In Islam
A
Variety of Views on Women and Islam
Kamel Daoud, "The Sexual Misery of
the Arab World", NYT, Sunday Review, Op-Ed, February 14, 2016
(translated from the French original)
@ http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/14/opinion/sunday/the-sexual-misery-of-the-arab-world.html?partner=rssnyt&emc=rss&_r=0.
Carla
Power/A
Secret History (On rediscovering female Islamic scholars of the
Middle Ages)/NYT Sunday Magazine February 25, 2007
"In the Middle Ages, many Islamic scholars were women. Will their
redicovery have an effect on Muslim women today?"
Neil
MacFarquhar/New
Translation Prompts Debate on Islamic Verse/NYT March 25, 2007
(revisited)
Lauren Weiner, "Islam and Women: Choosing to veil and
other paradoxes", Policy Review, October-November 2004,
No. 127.
Nilüfer
Göle/Visible
Women: Actresses in the Public Realm/New Perspectives
Quarterly/Spring 2004
Lila
Abu-Lughod/The
Muslim Woman: The power of images and the danger of
pity/Eurozine/September 01, 2006
"In the common Western imagination, the image of the veiled
Muslim woman stands for oppression in the Muslim world. This makes
it hard to think about the Muslim world without thinking about
women, sets up an "us" and "them" relationship with Muslim women,
and ignores the variety of ways of life practiced by women in
different parts of the Muslim world. Anthropologist Lila
Abu-Lughod emphasizes that veiling should not be confused with a
lack of agency or even traditionalism. Western feminists who take
it upon themselves to speak on behalf of oppressed Muslim women
assume that individual desire and social convention are inherently
at odds: something not borne out by the experience of Islamic
society."
Lorraine
Adams/Beyond
the Burka - an essay/NYT Sunday Book Review January 6, 2008
Muslim women’s voices are being heard as never
before. But which ones?
Sabrina
Tavirnese/In
Quest for Equal Rights, Muslim Women's Meeting Turns to Islam's
Tenets/NYTFebruary 16, 2009
Jane
Perlez/Muslims'
Veils Test Limits of Britain's Tolerance (with slide show)/NYT
June 22, 2007
Photo: A young British Muslim woman wears a full-face veil. http://graphics8.nytimes.com/images/2007/06/17/world/19veil5.jpg
Mariam
Lau/Stepping out of the fire (On the rights of
Muslim/Turkish women in Germany)/signandsight.com/features/937.html/Sep't.
06,
2006
"Having been violently attacked by
the husband of one of her clients, Berlin lawyer and Islam
critic Seyran Ateș has closed her legal practice. A fighter
for human rights resigns."
Elaine
Sciolino/Britain
Grapples With Role for Islamic Justice (w/photos)/NYT November
19, 2008 (revisited)
Christopher
Caldwell/Where
Every Generation Is First-Generation (Turkish women &
assimilation issues in Germany)/NYT Sunday Magazine, May 27,
2007
"Marriage is not just an aspect of the immigration problem in
Germany; to a growing extent, it is the immigration problem.
Starting in the 1960s, millions of Turkish “guest workers” were
imported to provide manpower for the German economic boom.
The guest-worker program was ended in 1973, the year of the first
oil crisis, but large-scale immigration from Turkey has scarcely
abated since.
... This leaves open only one avenue for non-European men
and women who want to enter Germany legally: marriage to someone
with legal residency in the country. Fortunately for
would-be immigrants, young ethnic Turks in Germany have a strong
tendency to marry people from the home country. Exact
statistics are hard to come by, but it is possible that as many as
50 percent of Turks (a word that in common parlance often includes
even those with German citizenship) seek their spouses abroad ...
. For most of the past decade, ... between 21,000 and 27,000
people a year have successfully applied at German consulates in
Turkey to form families in Germany. (Just under two-thirds of the
newcomers are women.) That means roughly half a million
spouses since the mid-1980s, which in turn means hundreds of
thousands of new families in which the children’s first language
is as likely to be Turkish as German. ... Binational
marriage alarms many Germans for two reasons. First, it
allows the Turkish community to grow fast at a time when support
for immigration is low. The Turkish population in Germany
multiplies not once in a life cycle but twice — at childbirth and
at marriage. Second, such marriages retard assimilation even
for those Turks long established in Germany. You frequently
hear stories from schoolteachers about a child of guest workers
who was a star pupil three decades ago but whose own children,
although born in Germany, struggle to learn German in grade
school. After half a
century of immigration, every new generation of Turks is still,
to a large extent, a first generation. (boldface
added) ... Turkish marriages are seldom Western-style
love matches. They are often arranged by parents. A
2003 study by the Federal Ministry of Family found that a quarter
of Turkish women in Germany hadn’t even known their partners
before they married. ... The tragedy of imported brides, Necla Kelek writes, is that they
will live in Germany but never arrive there." (boldface added)
Interview
with
Ayaan Hirsi Ali on National Public Radio (NPR)/May 9,
2006-Includes Backgrounder on Ayaan Hirsi Ali
Christopher
Hitchins/The Caged Virgin: Holland's shameful treatment
of Ayaan Hirsi Ali/slate.com/May 8, 2006
An Interview with Ayan-Hirsi-Ali-video clip @ http://hotair.com/archives/the-blog/2006/05/10/audio-ayaan-hirsi-ali-at-harvard/
Ayaan
Hirsi
Ali/Islam's Silent Moderates/NYT December 7, 2007
Barry
Gewen/Muslim
Rebel Sisters: At Odds With Islam and Each Other/NYT Week In
Review Sunday, April 27, 2008
Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Irshad Manji are two of the most
prominent and outspoken critics of what they and others see as
“mainstream Islam,” but their approaches couldn’t be more
different.
Rebecca
Hillauer/On Fadela Amara & young Muslim women in the
working class suburbs of
France/signandsight.com/features/288.html/March 8, 2005
Neil
MacFarquhar/To
Muslim Girls, Scouts Offer a Chance to Fit In/International
Herald Tribune/November 28, 2007
The Headscarf Debate @
http://www.qantara.de/webcom/show_article.php/_c-549/i.html
Joseph
Berger/'My
War at Home': A Muslim Woman's Critique of Custom/NYT/March 25,
2006
Norimitsu
Onishi/Head
Scarf Emerges as Indonesia Political Symbol (w/photos)/NYT July
3, 2009
The jilbab, the Islamic style of dress in which a woman covers
her head and neck, has become an issue in Indonesia’s presidential
campaign.
"Despite being the world’s most
populous Muslim nation, Indonesia does not have a tradition of
Islamic dress. Most Indonesian women started wearing the
jilbab in the last decade, after the fall in 1998 of President
Suharto, who had kept a close grip on Islamic groups.
(boldface added)
Fashion and clothing industry experts said the number of women
wearing jilbabs rose sharply in the past three years, for reasons
of religion, fashion or something undefined.
'If you ask 10 different women why they’re wearing jilbab, you’ll
get 10 different answers,' said Jetti R. Hadi, the editor in chief
of Noor, a magazine specializing in Muslim fashion, which features
jilbab-clad models on its cover. 'You cannot assume that because a
woman is wearing a jilbab, she’s a good Muslim'."
Photo:
A
stall in Jakarta selling Muslim head scarves, known in Indonesia
as jilbabs. Sales are booming in the country, where women
traditionally went unveiled.
Beverly
M.
Weber/Revealed by the Veil:
Undertanding France's Headscarf Debates/Humanities and
Social Sciences Net Online April, 2008 A
review of
Joan
Wallach
Scott/The Politics of the Veil (Princeton University Press 2007).
Rayyan
Al-Shawaf/Covering Up: What to
learn from the French debate over headscarves/Christianity
Today, May-June 2008 A review of John
R.
Bowen/Why The French Don't Like Headscarves (Princeton
University Press 2007) and Joan
Wallach
Scott/The Politics of the Veil (Princeton University Press 2007).
Neil
MacFarquhar/As
Barrier [between men and women] Comes Down, a Muslim Split
Remains/NYT June 25, 2006
Katherine
Zoepf/Islamic
Revival Led by Women Tests Syria's Secularism/NYT August 29,
2006
Katherine
Zoepf/A
Dishonorable Affair/NYT Sunday Magazine September 23, 2007
("Honor killings" in Syria)
"Zahra died from her wounds at the hospital the following
morning, one of about 300 girls and women who die each year in
Syria in so-called honor killings, according to estimates by
women’s rights advocates there. In Syria and other Arab countries,
many men are brought up to believe in an idea of personal honor
that regards defending the chastity of their sisters, their
daughters and other women in the family as a primary social
obligation. Honor crimes tend to occur, activists say, when men
feel pressed by their communities to demonstrate that they are
sufficiently protective of their female relatives’ virtue. Pairs
of lovers are sometimes killed together, but most frequently only
the women are singled out for punishment. Sometimes women are
killed for the mere suspicion of an affair, or on account of a
false accusation, or because they were sexually abused, or
because, like Zahra, they were raped.
...
Some advocates claim that Syria has an especially high number of
honor killings per capita, saying that the country is second or
third in the world. In fact, reliable statistics on honor killing
are nearly impossible to come by. The United
Nations
Population Fund says that about 5,000 honor killings take
place each year around the world, but since they often occur in
rural areas where births and deaths go unreported, it is very
difficult to count them by country. Some killings have been
recorded in European cultures, including Italy, and in Christian
or Druse communities in predominantly Muslim countries. But it is widely agreed that honor
killings are found disproportionately in Muslim communities,
from Bangladesh to Egypt to Great Britain. (boldface
added)
The Grand Mufti Ahmad Badr Eddin Hassoun, Syria’s
highest-ranking Islamic teacher, has condemned honor killing and
Article 548 in unequivocal terms. Earlier this year, when we met
for a rare interview in his spacious office on the 10th floor of
Syria’s ministry of religious endowments, he told me, “It
happens sometimes that a misogynistic religious scholar will
argue that women are the source of all kinds of evil.” In fact,
he said, the Koran does not differentiate between women and men
in its moral laws, requiring sexual chastity of both, for
example. The commonly held view that Article 548 is derived from
Islamic law, he said, is false.
With his tightly wound white turban and giant pearl ring,
the grand mufti is one of Syria’s most recognizable public
figures. He is a charismatic and generally popular sheik, but
because he is appointed by the state, many Syrians believe that
his views reflect those of the ruling party, and they may find
his teachings suspect as a result. In downtown Damascus, one man
I interviewed on the street declared that the grand mufti was
not a “real Muslim” if he believed in canceling Article 548.
“It’s an Islamic law to kill your relative if she errs,” said
the man, who gave his name as Ahmed and said that he learned of
Zahra’s story on Syrian television. “If the sheik tries to fight
this, the people will rise up and slit his throat.”
There are religious figures who defend the status quo. At a
conference on honor killing held this year at Damascus
University, Mohammed Said Ramadan al-Bouti, one of Syria’s most
esteemed clerics, maintained that the laws should not be
changed, defending them on the principle in Shariah law that
people who kill in defense of their property should be treated
with lenience (he is believed to have moderated his stance
since). When, at an earlier conference, the grand mufti
announced that he didn’t believe protecting a woman’s virginity
was the most important component of honor, many attendees were
upset. In response, a group of about a dozen women, all dressed
in the long black abayas that in Syria are usually worn by only
very conservative women, walked out of the room".
Katherine
Zoepf/Love
on Girls' Side of the Saudi Divide (with photos)/NYT May 13,
2008
Robert
F.
Worth/Challenging Sex Taboos, With Help From the Koran
(w/photo)/NYT June 6, 2009
"Wedad Lootah, a marital counselor in Dubai, is the author of
what for the Middle East is an amazingly frank new book of
erotic advice.
... in which she celebrates the female orgasm, confronts
taboo topics like homosexuality and urges Arabs to transcend the
backward traditions that limit their sexual happiness.
... In Saudi Arabia and other countries where the genders are
rigorously separated, many men have their first sexual
experiences with other men, which affects their attitudes toward
sex in marriage, Ms. Lootah said.
... In a region where “honor killings” of women who have sex
outside marriage remain fairly common, sex education is widely
viewed as a portal to sin. Genital cutting of women still takes
place in Egypt, though it is now illegal. Arab writers and
artists have begun to tackle these subjects."
Laura
Secor,
"Stolen Kisses: Iran's Sexual Revolutions", Nation December
15, 2008, Vol. 287, Issue 20.
Texas State University permalink. A valid Texas State
University User Name and password are required for access.
Michael
Slackman/Molding
the Ideal Islamic Citizen (Iran)/NYT-Week in Review/Sunday,
September 09, 2007 (revisited)
Photo
from
Slackman NYT article immediately above with caption: "CULTURE
BLEND Islamic strictures met Persian love of pleasure in a
Tehran shop in 2005 when a head scarf was pulled back to show
some hair."
Sabrina
Tavernise/Youthful
Voice Stirs Challenge to Secular Turks/NYT October 14, 2008
In a country that built its modern identity on secularism, the
embrace of religious identity is an act of rebellion.
Muslim Gays
Adam Nossiter, "Wielding Whip and a Hard New Law, Nigeria
Tries to ‘Sanitize’ Itself of Gays", NYT, Sunday, February 9,
2014.
http://nyti.ms/1g7gIoS
(NYT
permalink)
Timothy
Williams
and Tareq Maher/Iraq's Newly Open Gays Face Scorn and Murder/NYT
April 8, 2009
In a country that remains religious and conservative, the
response to a gay subculture has been swift and deadly.
Nicholas
Kulish/Gay
Muslims Pack a Dance Floor of Their Own (in Berlin)/NYT, January
1, 2008
Patrick
Healy/The
Provincetown (Beirut) of the Middle East (w/photos & slide
show)/NYT Travel Section Sunday, August 2, 2009
Beirut has re-emerged as the party capital of the Arab world,
particularly for gay and lesbian vacationers in search of a social
life denied to them at home.
"While homosexual activity (technically, sexual relations that
officials deem “unnatural”) is illegal in Lebanon, as in most of
the Arab world, Beirut’s vitality as a Mediterranean capital of
night life has fueled a flourishing gay scene — albeit one where
men can be nervous about public displays of affection and where
security guards at clubs can intercede if the good times turn too
frisky on the dance floor. But even more than the partying, Beirut
represents a different Middle East for some gay and lesbian Arabs:
the only place in the region where they can openly enjoy a social
life denied them at home.
...In Saudi Arabia, Yemen and
several other countries, homosexual acts are punishable by death."
(boldface
added)
Irshad
Manji/Confessions
of a Muslim Dissident: Why I Fight for Women, Jews, Gays, and
Allah/Audio
Irshad Manji addresses the ideas in her
international best-seller, "The Trouble with Islam Today:? A
Muslim's Call for Reform in Her Faith".
April 19, 2005 at the Goldman School of Public
Policy at UC Berkeley
Irshadd Manji's website: http://muslim-refusenik.com/
Gabrielle Glaser, "A Gay Muslim Filmmaker Goes Inside the
Hajj", NYT, September 24, 2015 @ http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/27/nyregion/parvez-sharma-a-sinner-in-mecca.html?ref=middleeast&_r=0
Recommended:
Azar
Nafisi/Reading
Lolita in Tehran: A Memoir in Books
See also: Nazila
Fathi/In
Iran, Tactics of Fashion Police Raise Concerns/NYT May 04, 2007
Nazila
Fathi/Starting
at home, Iran's women fight for rights/International Herald
Tribune February 13, 2009
Women's rights advocates say Iranian women are displaying a
growing determination to achieve equal status in this conservative
Muslim theocracy, where male supremacy is still enscribed in the
legal code.
Michiko
Kakutani/Life
in Iran, Where Freedom Is Deferred/NYT April 14, 2009
A review of: Azadeh
Moaveni,
Honeymoon in Tehran: Two Years
of Love and Danger in Iran (Random House 2009)
"One day in spring 2007, Ms. Moaveni reports: 'The authorities
launched the most ferocious crackdown on ‘un-Islamic’ dress in
over a decade. Overnight, they revised the tacit rules governing
women’s dress. The closets of millions of women across the country
contained nothing but short, tailored coats; ankle-length pants;
and bright headscarves. Suddenly, these styles were grounds for
arrest. In the days that followed, the police detained 150,000
women for failing to abide by the official dress code.'
'I suppose to people living in free countries where women wear
what they please, the difference between a relaxed dress code and
a stern one sounds inconsequential,' she writes. 'In fact, it
mattered desperately. In the years when women could wear colors,
could show off the lines of their figures, what in effect became
acceptable was the expression of individuality. Between the year
2000 until that April of 2007, I wore a headscarf and manteau in
Tehran, but I still looked, from head to toe, like Azadeh. I did
not resemble the thousands of other women on the street, but only
myself. As I presume was the case for most women, this helped me
to perceive the oppressive weight of the regime as lighter than it
perhaps actually was.'
In these pages Ms. Moaveni does an affecting job of conveying how
the Islamic government’s edicts permeated every aspect of people’s
private lives. Couples wishing to hold a 'mixed wedding,' where
men and women commingle, are advised to hire expensive security
details to guard against police raids. Baby names have to be
chosen with care so as to avoid forbidden names, including
European names, Kurdish names and the names of pre-Islamic Persian
heroes."
Read
the
first chapter of Honeymoon in Tehran by Azadeh Moaveni.
Anne
Applebaum/Woman Power (Iran-with photos of women protesters
& links to related articles on women in Islam &
Iran)/Slate June 22, 2009
Regimes that repress the civil and human rights of half their
population are inherently unstable.
"Women in sunglasses and head scarves speaking through
megaphones, brandishing cameras, carrying signs. When they first
appeared, the photographs of the 2005 Tehran University women's rights protests
were a powerful reminder of the true potential of Iranian women.
They were uplifting, they featured women of many ages, and they
went on circulating long after the protests themselves died down.
Now they have been replaced by a far more brutal and already
infamous set of images: the photographs and video taken last
weekend of a young Iranian woman, allegedly shot by a government
sniper, dying on the streets of Tehran."
Michael
Slackman/Cultural
Collisions in the Slow Lane to Modernity (w/photo of separate
sections for men & women at a McDonald's in Riyadh, Saudi
Arabia)/NYT May 09, 2007. The caption below the photo reads:
"At a golden-arched symbol of globalization in Riyadh,
modernity yields to tradition with separate sections for men and
completely covered women."
Robert
F.
Worth/As Taboos Ease, Saudi Girl Group Dares to Rock (w/link to
the group's website)/NYT November 24, 2008
Saudi Arabia’s first all-girl rock band has an underground hit
as the country’s harsh code of morals slowly thaws.
Michael
Slackman/A
Quiet Revolution in Algeria: Gains by Women/NYT May 26,
2007 (with photos depicting Algerian
women’s growing participation in society).
"In this tradition-bound nation scarred by a brutal Islamist-led
civil war that killed more than 100,000, a quiet revolution is
under way: women are emerging as an economic and political force
unheard of in the rest of the Arab world."
Norimitsu
Onishi/In
Singapore, a More Progressive Islamic Education/NYT April 23,
2009
Photo:
An
all-girls high school chemistry class taught at the Madrasa Al
Irsyad Islamiah in Singapore
A madrasa that balances religious and secular studies is seen
by the country’s Muslim leaders as the future of Islamic education
in Southeast Asia.
Michael
Slackman/In
Egypt, a Rising Push Against Genital Cutting/NYT September 20,
2007 (includes photo slide show)
"'The Koran is a newcomer to tradition in this manner,'
she said. 'As a male society, the men took parts of religion that
satisfied men and inflated it. The parts of the Koran that helped
women, they ignored.' ... It is an unusual swipe
at the Islamists who have
promoted the practice as in keeping with religion,
especially since the government generally tries to avoid taking on
conservative religious leaders. It tries to position itself as the
guardian of Islamic values, aiming to enhance its own wilted
legitimacy and undercut support for the Muslim Brotherhood, the
banned but popular opposition movement.But the religious discourse
concerning genital cutting has changed, ... " (boldface added)
Michael
Slackman/Dreams
Stifled, Egypt's Young Turn to Islamic Fervor (with
photos)/NYT February 17, 2008
Across the Middle East, many
people are forced to put off marriage, the gateway to
independence. In their frustration they turn to religion for
solace.
Video: Women &
Islam
**********************************************************************************
Academic Honesty
Statement
Learning and teaching take place best in an
atmosphere of intellectual freedom and openness. All members of
the academic community are responsible for supporting freedom
and openness through rigorous personal standards of honesty and
fairness. Plagiarism and other forms of academic dishonesty
undermine the very purpose of the university and diminish the
value of an education.
Academic Offenses
Students who have committed academic dishonesty,
which includes cheating on an examination or other academic work
to be submitted, plagiarism, collusion, or abuse of resource
materials, are subject to disciplinary action.
a. Academic work means the preparation of an
essay, thesis, report, problem assignments, or other projects
which are to be submitted for purposes of grade determination.
b. Cheating means:
1. Copying from another student?s test paper,
laboratory report, other report or computer files, data listing,
and/or programs.
2. Using materials during a test unauthorized by
person giving test.
3. Collaborating, without authorization, with
another person during an examination or in preparing academic
work.
4. Knowingly, and without authorization, using,
buying, selling, stealing, transporting, soliciting, copying, or
possessing, in whole or part, the content of an unaministered
test.
5. Substituting for another student?or permitting
another person to substitute for oneself in taking an exam or
preparing academic work.
6. Bribing another person to obtain an
unadministered test or information about an unadministered test.
c. Plagiarism means the appropriation of
another's work and the unacknowledged incorporation of that
work in one's own written work offered for credit.
(Underline Added)
d. Collusion means the unauthorized collaboration
with another person in preparing written work offered for
credit.
e. Abuse of resource materials means the
mutilation, destruction, concealment, theft or alteration of
materials provided to assist students in the mastery of course
materials.
Penalties for Academic Dishonesty
Students who have committeed academic dishonesty
may be subject to:
a. Academic penalty including one or more of the
following when not inconsistent:
1. A requirement to perform additional academic
work not required of other students in the course;
2. Required to withdraw from the course with a
grade of F. (Underline Added)
3. A reduction to any level grade in the course,
or on the exam or other academic work affected by the academic
dishonesty.
b. Disciplinary penalty including any penalty
which may be imposed in a student disciplinary hearing pursuant
to this Code of Conduct.
****************************************************************************************************
Civility in the
classroom is very important
for the educational process and it is
everyone’s responsibility. If you have
questions about appropriate behavior in a
particular class, please address them with
your instructor first. Disciplinary
procedures may be implemented for refusing
to follow.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
B.A. in POLITICAL SCIENCE - LEARNING OUTCOMES:
1. Students will demonstrate the ability to
ask relevant questions pertaining to Political Science.
2. Students will demonstrate the ability to
recognize and evaluate assumptions and implications.
3. Students will demonstrate the ability to
examine and evaluate different sides of an issue.
4. Students will demonstrate the ability to
state and defend a thesis that is clear, direct, logical, and
substantive in the area of Political Science.
5. Students will demonstrate the ability to
find and use a variety of appropriately cited sources.
6. Students will demonstrate substantive
knowledge of concepts and facts relevant to Political Science.
For students in Public Administration:
BPA – PROGRAM
LEARNING OUTCOMES:
1. Students will demonstrate critical thinking
and problem solving skills.
2. Students will demonstrate the ability to
communicate effectively in writing.
3. Students will demonstrate effective oral
communication skills.
4. Students will demonstrate a fundamental
understanding of key public administration and management concepts
related to their internship experience or applied research
project.
5. Students will demonstrate an understanding of
ethical issues in public administration.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________